I’ve only really gotten into one game that could be considered a GaaS, and that’s Destiny. But it’s more of a hybrid of genres. It has some of the best gun play mechanics I’ve ever played- going around shooting fucks FEELS fun as hell.
And while there is a lot of single player content, the game really shines playing that content with friends in a fireteam. And the rewards are loot in the form of better guns and gear.
There’s some very light RPG elements with a leveling system, and different subclasses that work in tandem with others. The game is straight awesome on a fundamental level.
The problem is content. Throughout both games there have been content droughts, or questionable decisions on how the game will operate moving forward. For example, the first year of Destiny 2 was a huge step back in terms of features and playable activities on offer. Coming from the end of D1 with the last expansion Rise of Iron, which was amazing, the decision to scale shit back was unacceptable and it lost a lot of players (myself included) after they beat the initial campaign and the Raid. There just wasn’t much incentive to keep playing.
But then the Forsaken expansion came out and it put the Destiny franchise in a better place than it has ever been, content wise. People started to come back and play it (myself included). Even the season framework was working, with new series introduced, and new cool activities to keep you busy while also having fun.
And then again with Shadowkeep. We could go back to the Moon and all of a sudden there was a ton of cool shit to do again. New Raid, new Dungeons, Vex Offensive, Nightmare shits, it was fucking awesome.
And then the next season starts and it’s one new activity, MAYBE five hours of story, and a bunch of grindy fetch quest bullshit.
All this to say that the service provided from Bungie in support of Destiny has been INCONSISTENT. And that’s a problem. The great heights of videogame greatness followed by stupid shit only the diehards want to stick around for. And it’s a shame because the good stuff is really fucking good. But that’s how they get you to keep spending money.
I feel that, if done right, games like Destiny could really be the best shit ever. But corporate greed gets in the way of it all. I’m interested to see what Destiny 3 will look like after Bungie has been away from Activision and can build their game in their own vision for a new console generation.