Return of Shiki:
> I suppose you forgot you get plenty of free items for catching frogs for Frog Drop. So there goes another argument out the window.
No , I didnât forget. I didnât bother to mention it because the items either arenât that good or can be found elsewhere with less hassle. Last I checked, You get 5 items for catching frogs: Silk Robe (I suppose itâs okay early on), Elixir (bleh), some forks (good for Quina, but as you said, whoâs using her physical attack?), and a Battle Boots (good, but you can more easily buy these). This in no way compares to the dozens of items and equipment you get from stealing, or the experience you get for killing Grand Dragons.
> And it takes WAY longer to build up Thievery than Frog Drop.
To 9999 damage maybe, maybe. But Thievery can hit big damage a lot earlier than Frog Drop if youâre stealing constantly (which is almost a given). Frog Drop only gets powered up in spurts, and there are times when you canât really power it up at all because the frogs donât regenerate fast enough. Stealing is at least constant. AND, in the meantime, Zidane at least can kill things without Thievery (regular physical attack and Trance abilities) and survives better due to higher HP/def, and youâre not stuck in some damn swamp doing nothing else. Quinaâs still sucking until she gets Frog Drop at decent levels, and continues to die the most easily even after she gets to do 9999 damage.
> And Blue Magic SUCKED in FF5 and FF6 (and FF10 if you want to count the Blue Ape as a blue mage)
Blue Magic was just as good as regular magic in FFVI. Most of the blue magic spells were rubbish, just as most of the regular magic spells were either rubbish or became obsolete after a time (i.e. after you got Ultima). True, nothing was as good as Ultima, except maybe Vanish-Doom, but Grand Train and Quasar were almost as good if you didnât feel like glitching your way through the game. White Wind was a potentially better healer than Cure 3. Big GUard was still awesome (though hardly necessary if you had Marvel Shoes).
Admittedly, I can barely remember using blue magic in V. Time Magic was boss in that game.
Blue Magic isnât that good in X, yeah. Well, not quite: Mighty Guard, Bad Breath and Stone Breath are all great. But since theyâre overdrive spells, and you canât abuse Overdrives like you can in VIII, theyâre really not worth using.
However, Blue Magic rocked in VII. Hands down the best version of blue magic ever. Trine (when you first get it), Aqua Breath, Shadow Flare, Pandoraâs Box, Angelâs Whisper (best healing spell in the game), White Wind, Bad Breath, Big Guard, and probably a few others Iâm forgetting. All great spells.
BLue Magic was also good in VIII, albeit only if you abused the skip-turn glitch and kept Quitis at low HP (and since this was the to play in all but two battles, why wouldnât you?). Degenerator/Bad Breath/Shockwave Pulsar every turn for free? Fuck IXâs shitty blue magic.
> It was at its best in FF9 and FFTA.
VI, VII and VIII > IX. Dunno about FFT.