The meidic was always a very survivable class once you realized its specifically designed for support while staying behind cover, and that BY DESIGN his weapons are not particularly powerful and BY DESIGN he didn’t have a huge sum of health in order to encourage you to play the role the class was built for. Seriously, theres a post about it somewhere on the TF2 blog, early on, the needlegun was a GOOD weapon, but because of that there was really very little reason to play medic as a medic. Now, does this mean a scout could run behind your lines and fuck you up? Yup, but thats why its a team dynamics based game. If any class needed a survivability buff, it was pyro, since doesn’t even really have the damage output IN HIS IDEAL RANGE as soldier/demo, but when he got that it was just a shitstorm.
When it was first released, the kritzkrieg didn’t really charge very much faster at all, while it still had its uses on occasion, the regular ubergun at medic patch release was almost entirely better. Nowadays, sure, kritz has a lot of uses thanks to its fast ubercharge rate.
I wasn’t accusing you specifically of having said the FaN was OP, but its something a lot of people complain about even though its basically completely backwards.
I personally haven’t seen this play out this way, but I haven’t really played much since the soldier update anyways, I’m just going off the initial impressions the people I generally play with gave me, most of whom are quite good.
The fact is, no unlocks, NONE of them, have had a real, lasting impact on the way a class plays out in its role or how overall powerful the class is. I can see not wanting them in comp for various reasons, but I fail to see the logic in getting rid of all of them EXCEPT the medic weapons, the ones which made the biggest (although admittedly still small) impact on what, quite frankly, was already one of the most powerful classes.
This is the opposite of what I said. I said there was no reason to use the bonesaw over the ubersaw.
Some real not reading what I actually wrote in here. Please don’t accuse me of things I didn’t say.