I seriously wrote this goddamn huge post re: Santa Claus and am goddamned pissed that my browser crashed. Fuck. Here are the new official tiers.
MacBauer Tier: MacBauer
Top Tier: c.hp, Batman
Roll Tier: Google Chrome
Ok. Well, here’s the gist of it.
Santa Claus may not have super speed. The reason being is that in order for Santa to physically be as fast as he must be to complete his mission, he would just about have to travel the speed of light. If this were the case, at the speed of light matter breaks down into molecules and Santa could just beam in and out of every house on Christmas Eve. However, Santa still has flying reindeer and a sled which carries an improbable amount of presents; this would be completely unnecessary if Santa could travel at light speed, and this would run counter to his MO of being able to efficiently deliver presents to every Christmas-celebrating household every year.
Instead, Santa may have a distorted sense of time. This means that for every second from our normal perspective that passes, minutes or even hours could pass for Santa. This would then give Santa conceivably several months to accomplish his task, making it more plausible. From our perspective, this would be “super-speed,” but in reality, Santa exists in a different temporal plane. This would also account for his apparent immortality; he may not be immortal at all, and may be hundreds of years old, but from his physical time distorted perspective, he could be in his '60s. If this is the case, it has been shown that objects in a slower temporal perspective can interact with objects from a “Normal” perspective, but it would cause a great force to be exerted. In other words, if slowed-down Santa punched you in the face, it would feel like getting hit by an 18-wheeler going 120 mph.
Santa is shown to know the moral fortitude of young Christian children. Either he has a psychic hivemind of elves policing our minds, or the elves have the complete technological supremacy to monitor our actions undetected, using tech that must be many times more state of the art than anything coming out of an American weapons manufacturer’s lab, or a Japanese science firm. That’s hardcore.
However, the vast majority of people on Earth aren’t Christian children who celebrate Christmas. That may number in the hundreds of millions, but Santa has not been shown to deliver presents to African tribesmen. Either this is because he simply does not care for them, or they exist outside of his sphere of manipulation.
Another interpretation on the identity of Santa himself is that he is not physically a man with an elf factory who lives at the North Pole, but rather a living zeitgeist of the Western European appropriation of the traditional Winter Solstice celebration; that is, he is a literal, living spirit of Christmas, and is the driving force that causes people around the world to buy each other gifts. If this is the case, then Santa himself is a spirit of either demonstrative altruism, or consumer capitalism. If it is the former, than Santa Claus is an avatar of love, kindness and peace. If it is the latter, then Santa Claus is the spirit of The Man himself, the wealthy, oppressive, White Anglo Saxon Protestant force that has kept The Man in power since the days of European colonialism and well into today. If this interpretation holds true, then Santa Claus could theoretically be defeated by the coming political and economic prominence of contemporary China, who would reclaim the Mandate of Heaven from our White masters.
If Batman faces Santa Claus (physical being, temporal distortion), Santa may very well know the schematics of Wayne Manor and the Batcave, as it is a domicile and part of his MO.
“When you were nine years old, all you wanted for Christmas was for your mother and father to not be murdered in a cold, dark alleyway. But you were naughty. Your father had to tell you things twice all year long, didn’t he? You were a bad boy, Bruce. You didn’t get what you wanted on Christmas.”
Hm. On second thought, this would either reduce Batman to a snivelling mess, or would piss him off. If it were a fight he wanted, Santa could theoretically have tech that could match or beat the Wayne Industries tech, and the time distortion example shows that a punch from Santa would really fucking hurt. Bruce would have to play footsies the whole damn match. Ridiculous damage or not, Santa does have a large hitbox in the form of his gut. Santa’s boots are likely resistant to slipping since he lives in the icy-as-fuck North Pole, therefore antispray corner trap might not be as effective here.
I would think that Santa’s “speed” would be kinda like Genei Jin. Think about that; Genei Jin w/ Gief damage levels per hit. Well. Shit. That’s pretty broke. Batman could batarang spam but with Santa’s speed he’ll just keep trading projectiles.
One-on-one, this fight might actually be in Santa’s favor, which is why Batman would have to lay out a trap. Bats lures Santa out to an abandoned building loaded with C4. Ordinarily, Santa could just read his mind and know the trap is coming, but Bruce’s mind is ridiculously trained; he would find a way to lay the trap out subconsciously so that not even a psychic hivemind Santa could detect it.
In other words, Batman can win this… with prep-time!
If Batman faces Santa Claus (as spirit of altruism and love and kindness to one another)… Well, I guess Batman would just have to be an asshole and win that way.
If Batman faces Santa Claus (zeitgeist of the rich white man)… in that case, with Wayne Industries being the foremost tech firm in the world, wouldn’t Santa Claus already be inside of, and responsible for, Batman?
I want to hear others’ thoughts on this as well.