If I was a Dormant I’d just be as silent as possible. They’re not going to join our side at this point, except maybe out of pity, until we re-establish a heavy advantage.
However this tells us something very important. At least one member of the Mafia was online at the end of the phase, I’m certain. Forge made this post about 9 hours before deadline:
She bolded Hange, and then in the immediate next post explained precisely why she brought that fact up. That’s what Forge does when she uses codes. I was really hoping Mafia wouldn’t pick up on that.
So, these two facts:
-Mafia was online, possibly without posting, at end of night
-Mafia knew Forge’s tendencies, at least with regards to codes
This puts Syn & Alpha higher on my list in particular.
@Augustus you have one day left to earn that S-Tier placement, show us what you got.
Chief, I like how you’re quick to agree, and quick to slip in votes without talking in the thread, getting your vote in just before me. You’re so invisible around here you might as well be flying a B2 Bomber
If I had to pick someone I want as the opposing wagon to mine it would be you by this point. Your contributions this game have been beyond weak. Normally you’re out for blood with a tenacity few can match. Yet, since deciding I’m mafia all you’ve done is agree with popular opinion, put an inconsequential vote on me and disappeared for the rest of the time.
You’ve been AWOL this game yourself. In fact we both were barely here days 1 and 2. And like I said before, you said you somehow knew Gamer had a role after he died even though you were supposedly busy for 30 hours (and before you say I talked to him like last time I checked. You only responded to him once on page 1 at the beginning, and there you were answering something for him.) So either you guessed in between the time you were paying attention to the thread and when you left or you were role hunting in your spare time.
If it’s not you it would be Pimp Willy. I know he can read Forge well personally and I have a good feeling he could read Gamer as well.
(FYI, holding off on actually voting until Forge LG’s.)
I’m the first to admit I haven’t done much this game. I was trying on day 1 to get some discussion going but everyone seemed content to sit around. D2 was just depressing. If it’s my wagon this time, I’m going to do my best to leave at least something for civs to go on.
And I explained my read on gamer. My first post in the thread was talking about expedition phases, and he immediately agreed with me that expedition was a great idea. The people that stood to gain the most from that plan were civilian power roles. I then mentioned something ambiguous about wanting to see more of him in the thread and he didn’t go defensive, leading me to feel he was civilian.
PW has been someone I’ve been suspicious of all game but I’m not certain he’s guilty. TBH, if not you then Chief at this point.
Black Chiefus has decided to grace us with his presence. Any more insight, or even reasoning for lynching me?
Best case scenario: The Mafia have 4 members and investigated the Dormant Lover the first night, then investigated a civilian last night. Four Mafia, eighteen Civilians.
Realistic scenario: The Mafia have 5 members as they recruited a Dormant last night after investigating him the first night. Five Mafia, seventeen Civilians.
Worst case scenario: The Mafia have 6 members, recruiting players successfully both nights. Six Mafia, sixteen Civilians.
Going by numbers we’re actually not at a huge disadvantage. It just feels like we’re getting the shit beat out of us because our power roles are dying and only about 12 players are actually posting with any significant frequency.
I’m going to start putting this at the end of all my posts to @ everybody and remind us of who all’s “playing” without doing anything.
I still don’t see why you’re expecting me to actually be able to do anything when I said well before we started that I can’t play these kind of games. Yet you insisted on me playing anyway.
Whatever. Might as well go for baseless accusations now.