Is that a role that usually goes unlisted? Dont see anything like that in the role cards.
Night 1 Info Dump
-Lots of dead weight votes. Mafia most likely to kill a solo/no voter tonight.
-Combo_Knight potential to be an unsuccessful Mafia lynch train.
-Mafia unlikely to put all three votes on same person, but likely that at least one voted for one of the top three.
-Ignore orochizoolander and Sumazndude for the time being.
-Forcing Day 2’s vote to Combo_Knight, Blindknagg and Augustus gives 2 days worth of information, abandon if better suspect arises.
-Mafia unlikely to vote for Mafia Day 1 unless voting solo as future reference.
-Side note: Colossal Titan not activated. Colossal/Female either not in top 3 or non-titan was expected to receive more votes. Most likely latter.
-Assumption that Female Titan kills all other members in group except Levi/Mikasa proven incorrect. Expedition phases are now viable with Female Titan alive.
Suggested Day 3 Course of Action: Expedition Phase with the following layout:
Group 1: Blindknagg
Group 2: Combo_Knight
Group 3: Augustus
Group 4: Everyone Else
-Mafia options limited to killing 1 of 3 top suspects during phase.
-If 1 of 3 lynched Day 2, replace with another suspect.
-Check thread for flaws in layout. If none, propose this formation for every possible Expedition Phase, run Expedition Phases at every possible chance.
Night Phase:
-Only person that can take Night action Day 1 is Hange Zoe.
-Reiteration: Protect player should not be used except in 1 of 2 conditions:
-End-game
-Strong-roled Civilian is revealed Day phase
-Do not investigate any of Day 1’s top vote receivers. They will be dealt with shortly. List of investigation targets becomes useful mid/end-game. Investigate potential mid/end-game players.
New suspect: The Co-Jones
Order of voting preference:
Blindknagg
The Co-Jones
Cyntalan
ForgeDigger
Night 1 Info Dump
-Lots of dead weight votes. Mafia most likely to kill a solo/no voter tonight.
-Combo_Knight potential to be an unsuccessful Mafia lynch train.
-Mafia unlikely to put all three votes on same person, but likely that at least one voted for one of the top three.
-Ignore orochizoolander and Sumazndude for the time being.
-Forcing Day 2’s vote to Combo_Knight, Blindknagg and Augustus gives 2 days worth of information, abandon if better suspect arises.
-Mafia unlikely to vote for Mafia Day 1 unless voting solo as future reference.
-Side note: Colossal Titan not activated. Colossal/Female either not in top 3 or non-titan was expected to receive more votes. Most likely latter.
-Assumption that Female Titan kills all other members in group except Levi/Mikasa proven incorrect. Expedition phases are now viable with Female Titan alive.
Suggested Day 3 Course of Action: Expedition Phase with the following layout:
Group 1: Blindknagg
Group 2: Combo_Knight
Group 3: Augustus
Group 4: Everyone Else
-Mafia options limited to killing 1 of 3 top suspects during phase.
-If 1 of 3 lynched Day 2, replace with another suspect.
-Check thread for flaws in layout. If none, propose this formation for every possible Expedition Phase, run Expedition Phases at every possible chance.
Night Phase:
-Only person that can take Night action Day 1 is Hange Zoe.
-Reiteration: Protect player should not be used except in 1 of 2 conditions:
-End-game
-Strong-roled Civilian is revealed Day phase
-Do not investigate any of Day 1’s top vote receivers. They will be dealt with shortly. List of investigation targets becomes useful mid/end-game. Investigate potential mid/end-game players.
New suspect: The Co-Jones
Order of voting preference:
Blindknagg
The Co-Jones
Cyntalan
ForgeDigger
Night 1 Info Dump
-Lots of dead weight votes. Mafia most likely to kill a solo/no voter tonight.
-Combo_Knight potential to be an unsuccessful Mafia lynch train.
-Mafia unlikely to put all three votes on same person, but likely that at least one voted for one of the top three.
-Ignore orochizoolander and Sumazndude for the time being.
-Forcing Day 2’s vote to Combo_Knight, Blindknagg and Augustus gives 2 days worth of information, abandon if better suspect arises.
-Mafia unlikely to vote for Mafia Day 1 unless voting solo as future reference.
-Side note: Colossal Titan not activated. Colossal/Female either not in top 3 or non-titan was expected to receive more votes. Most likely latter.
-Assumption that Female Titan kills all other members in group except Levi/Mikasa proven incorrect. Expedition phases are now viable with Female Titan alive.
Suggested Day 3 Course of Action: Expedition Phase with the following layout:
Group 1: Blindknagg
Group 2: Combo_Knight
Group 3: Augustus
Group 4: Everyone Else
-Mafia options limited to killing 1 of 3 top suspects during phase.
-If 1 of 3 lynched Day 2, replace with another suspect.
-Check thread for flaws in layout. If none, propose this formation for every possible Expedition Phase, run Expedition Phases at every possible chance.
Night Phase:
-Only person that can take Night action Day 1 is Hange Zoe.
-Reiteration: Protect player should not be used except in 1 of 2 conditions:
-End-game
-Strong-roled Civilian is revealed Day phase
-Do not investigate any of Day 1’s top vote receivers. They will be dealt with shortly. List of investigation targets becomes useful mid/end-game. Investigate potential mid/end-game players.
New suspect: The Co-Jones
Order of voting preference:
Blindknagg
The Co-Jones
Cyntalan
ForgeDigger
Fuck Vanilla Forums. Leaving triple-posted eyesore to avoid unnecessary accusations.
Fuck Vanilla Forums. Leaving triple-posted eyesore to avoid unnecessary accusations.
Fuck Vanilla Forums. Leaving triple-posted eyesore to avoid unnecessary accusations.
Damn. Talk about bad luck Brian over here. Your complaint on a triple post turned into a triple as well 
A tie huh? I’d rather have been lynched than have that happen to be honest since then the rest of you could have learned something out of my death. Seems like we have a lot of silent voters this game too.
The forums are slow as shit today. Tried to post this one hour ago but it apparently did not go through.
Wizard mustve completely emptied the McRib reserves. This will make playing Mafia a problem. I was staring at a 503 error like the last hour and a half.
It wouldn’t be so hard since the vote count within the last two hours of deadline was a tie anyway.
Voting Aug would have been easier, but DG did say earlier he was against the Aug vote, so for him to backtrack on his words would make him look dirtier. So next best thing for mafia with one last vote would be to force a hung vote. The vote counts for C_K and BK were all publicly announced and DG locks in his vote in the last 30 minutes.
Of course this sounds all too easy. But… @DarkGeneral you explained your thought process above when voting, but did you not take into account the vote count?
@Bious FYI I did explain my vote with a little chat with Skizzz. I voted DukeC off of a hunch because I thought he wanted me off because he assumed I had a power role. He could be role hunting?
Kind of weird coming from someone who did not vote Bious.
I voted in a manner to ensure we don’t shoot ourselves in the foot.
-
TGG I know it doesn’t look like he’s halfway decent at the game, or even taking it seriously, but Augustus’s playstyle can be useful. Don’t write him off just for that. Besides, if you think he’s bad just be glad you didn’t see great cow lord’s play. GCL was smart and had fantastic moments, but then he’d do outright illogical stuff like tying the vote when it was lynch-or-lose
-
For whoever was saying there might be a Serial Killer I think “the assassin was among them” was just referring to the Mafia who killed MP in the writeup
-
Hange, just a reminder. Alpha’s hit the nail on the head with your actions. Don’t protect unless someone’s claimed and is essentially dead that night phase, and investigate players who are going to survive to endgame. Getting an Innocent result on a player who’s going to survive to the end is fantastic, especially without a Forger. Getting a Guilty result on a player who’s getting lynched the next day anyway doesn’t change jack
-
@ Da Chief why’d you vote for Recessiontime? I know you have your reasons, and I understand if you’d rather not state them, but I can’t figure it out. If you were going for the inactive vote then he was just one of at least 6, given your standards, but if you saw anything in his post then I didn’t notice it and I’m curious. Right now we’re in a very odd triangle of suspects, and as I explain in a minute it just doesn’t add up. A new perspective, and maybe a new suspect, could help get us back into the right mentality
-
As odd as it sounds I feel more people had good reasons for voting Blindknagg as opposed to Combo_Knight
-Alpha pointed out there’s a lot of “first time mafia behaviour”
-Combo_Knight was voting him for self-preservation, which isn’t indicative of allegiance
-Exodus voted BK because he jumped on C_K’s edit and hasn’t responded to people that mentioned him
-DG claims BK is playing like a Dormant Titan would, trying to stall until he’s recruited, and presumably he’d rather go after a roleless/Dormant read than a Roled/Mafia read this early in the game?
-Blindknagg voted C_K for self-preservation, again doesn’t mean much of anything
-D offered absolutely zero input on anything, including his vote. “After reading throughout the thread” he voted C_K
-Cynt voted C_K presumably because everyone else was going to. He mentioned that his “fate was sealed after that edit” but doesn’t say much more on it
-Co Jones voted C_K thinking the edit was a Mafia mistake. He also pointed out that if C_K was actually Mafia they would probably use the Colossal Titan’s ability to end the day phase immediately even though it had been discussed that Hannes has literally nothing better to do than block that ability for the next two days. He’s voting for Combo while also pointing out that “if he was really Mafia” something would happen. Seems like he’s trying to make Combo seem clean while also voting for him
In addition, Blindknagg having more votes later in the day makes sense. There wasn’t one thing he did that was a giant flag on its own, it was multiple factors. There’s still not a situation that wraps all of this up and makes sense though. It’s possible that Combo is Mafia and Mafia pushed B_K because they thought they could get some traction, but neither Exodus or DG really pushed Blindknagg so much as voted for him in the second half of day phase while stating their reasoning, and Alpha’s been pushing him for a long time, before Combo’s edit IIRC. In addition it’d also be easier to push Augustus since their votes were tied for most of the day. If he’s civilian they get a civilian lynched, and if he’s Mafia then 2 of their 3 members are close to getting lynched and abandoning one to gain credibility for the other two is the logical choice.
It just doesn’t make sense to me.
He was “paying his debt” to Alpha of voting for me Day 1. You know, cause that’s more important than breaking a tie.
Announcing that something is locked and it actually being locked are two different things
I didn’t lock any vote prematurely this game or the last one I was in.
I don’t have to explain if I’m not asked.
And you post a lot but it’s bullshit all the same, it sounds like you just wanna craft me into a different type of player.
Fuzz, when you say “D” are you referring to D’Nyc3? Cuz if you are - you’ve got some errors in your big post above. Also - new suspect, new mentality sounds good, but should we wait til this night phase is over before delving into it?
oh nvm on the D thing, you are right
Yeah, D = Dnyc3
I realized that his name wasn’t “Dync3” so Dynce isn’t close
I’ll leave it up to everyone if they want to talk about something during night phase or not. Mafia have very few actions they can take in this setup, the only thing they can do is kill or investigate someone different, so the repercussions aren’t as bad. On our side Hange could investigate someone new because her original target is being looked at as a legitimate suspect.
I posted my reasons for voting BK yesterday. I dont know why my vote seemed to surprise some of you.
At work now why did Jason vote CK?