So, the thread’s totally blown up before the end of the day, we’ve had someone edit, BullDancer has sorta role claimed, PWilly has announced a “winning strat” and argues for it, Pistol Shrimp has been lynched, and someone no-lynch. Is that all for a day 1 checklist? Did I miss anything?
Unless someone can convince me on MP or PWilly, though, I’m gonna throw down for Combo_Knight.
[details=Spoiler]
Not locked. Ton of time left. Convince me to vote for someone less helpful than you such as infrequent lurker or some of your choices to sway and change my vote
at the least if you and others weren’t aware, finding the Valedictorian is really important, this medic find is not.[/details]
The Valedictorian is one person who has the ability to kill 3 players every night phase. If he’s wrong about the guess, they just get a “No-Kill” night for their team. In fact I just considered they can do this another time right? Kill 3 more players in another phase?
Its not a one time use according to the wording. Like even if they eventually get it right, it isn’t just 1 stock that’s used up. Missing asked if this was too powerful right away in the sign up thread but it was just answered and not changed to have any negatives if they fail to kill by not having all 3 choices correct.
Valedictorian won’t be found by detective as they only know he’s just another mafia. He could also have the forger on his side, the same role that has the chance to find the Valedictorian.
So what me and Pimp talked about back there with the No-Kills strategy by choosing that guy or just killing nonstop can instead be a waiting game
with these other roles taken and they already have a no-kill ability with a huge upside -
Valedictorian is not how I might have also thought it was.
Those Darth Chef, head mafia godfather roles.
As in: when investigated, they turn up clean.
Valedictorian should still turn up as Mafia.
I’m sure they do control the night kills until killed and someone else gets that designation, but the 3 kill move is only for Valedictorian. if he dies, they lose that major game changer one.
Compare my post average to the wall flowers please?
If we are all for lynching inactives, why is there a 3 vote count on a person who is reasonably active versus three different infrequent posters who has done absolutely nothing except post an objective view to a discussion thewy haven’t even bothered to participate in?