Pimp Willy, for RedD to be a mafia would be a bombshell, honestly. It would blow my mind and make me look highly suspicious. Could the mafia be targeting one of their own as a way to earn the civilian’s good graces? That would be extreme mindgames. It would work well, too, since RedD is banned. However, I do not think that is the case now, just based off of last game. People here aren’t gonna be that clever, especially on the first turn. Does the possibility exist? Yes, but I don’t give this group of people that much credit. I was the brains of the operation last time, and I’m pretty sure the start of SRK Mafia II has been pretty straight-forward…and yes I still suspect you of being mafia hehe 
I told you!
Umm what? That is a rather large deviation from the rules. I understand that you are the narrator and have arbitrary powers, but unless you explain your rationale for this decision not to reveal their roles, it reeks of favoritism…and no, “early stages” is not a sufficient explanation for this rule deviation…
In fact, this is highly biased against the civilians. They are the ones who need information the most, and yet you are arbitrarily saying “nope, not this round!” 2 people are gone, and we have no recourse as to what they were? Come on…
we should go with the assumption of worst case scenario, they were civilians.
how about we don’t go off assumptions.
game master: regardless of a person rage quitting or getting lynch , you should still put them in a write up and reveal if they are a civilian or a mafia member.
/really does suck for kane_warhead to act all salty in this game.might be an awesome person in real life/forums, but this game gave me an impression of a spoil sport.
at this early stage of the game that’s all we have to go off of. By assuming they were both civilians that gives us the worst possible scenario for us to plan for going forward. Unless…of course you have some insider knowledge you would be willing to share with us…
The only people who could possibly think Kane wasn’t mafia, in my head, is other mafia.
That being said, the whole strategy of who to vote off first and how to follow it up goes completely out the window, we’ll have to see who the mafia take out with their free hit
I can respect that, i’m just trying to plan for the statistically worst case scenario. Based on his last post i too believe him to be mafia(strictly because he was upset about the witness as i stated in the last page mind you) but for planning purposes since it’s not going to be revealed to us to my understanding.
Either way how do you guys think we should proceed?
Guess we’re gonna have to wait and see what the mafia does, honestly without any solid info we’re still back at the start. If I get time I’ll post up a list of who wanted who out and then we can pick somebody off either list to focus on.
We know kane was upset because SOMEBODY was right, that’s why he quit. We have to look and see who that might be. In order to know this, he’d have to have been upset at somebody who called out multiple people as mafia instead of just us voting randomly. I guess go back and look at who those people might possibly be, and vote based on what they thought.
Unless the whole kane thing is a huge setup and midfuck; sacrifice 2 mafia (redd and Kane) to reset the game to neutral, but then if thats the case we’ve probably already lost anyway at that genius level planning haha
Last post
I admit my post was stupid. I was pissed off in real life and it affected me even here in this game. I realized now that what I did was immature. Sorry for acting like a salty player in this game.
this game is going by sooo fast. iirc it didn’t get this hectic until the very end.
Everyone is tripping already, quite fun lol.
yea, this round makes me wish i played last round haha. If you think about it though all it did was jump 2 rounds on the civy side, hell if what we think is right we already eliminated a mafioso and we really didn’t have to do anything lol.
i’m excited to see how the rest of this “day” goes haha.
Tally:
RedD: 13 votes
supreme jd: 5 votes
great cow lord: 1 vote
kane_warhead: 1 vote
In 24 hours the game will switch to Night Time.
I don’t want to spell out everything, but all civilians I urge you to carefully read every post in this thread, Pimp Willy is wrong I’m sure there is enough info already for us to determine who to lynch next since redd is done.
D: I missed sign-ups, fuck.
It’s like a powder keg of excitement in this thread!
So, even though it looks like we’re not gonna know if redd and Kane were civilians or Mafia, we still have gotten a lot of information in this thread. The way Kane bitch quit pretty much is a sign that he’s mafia, since he was upset that “It’s clear somebody knows who all the mafia are and that breaks the game,” and the only way he could have known this was to be mafia. Unless his secret role was to quit the game early and pretend to be mafia, he’s 99% likely to be mafia. So lets track down his last 2 game posts:
http://shoryuken.com/f3/srk-mafia-ii-247621/index4.html#post9393980
and then followed by
http://shoryuken.com/f3/srk-mafia-ii-247621/index4.html#post9396003
That leaves us with about 20 posts between them that could have triggered this response, which means someone in there must have hit the nail on the head to make him bitch out and call quitsies.
Great Cow Lord in this time puts out a bunch of really long winded, rambling posts that quite frankly I can’t really follow without my head hurting. But he does call out Supreme JD and Kane as a mafia multiple times. Even though this goes against what I’d been arguing and believing throughout the first round, it does make sense that it might have ticked off Kane in that he was right.
Pimp Willy, I try to argue that we should hold the line and not let the obvious mafia distractions change our vote, since we have no clue on who anybody could be at this point we should just stay the course and see the result and go from there, this argument turns out to be futile since the role will stay hidden : / It is conceivable that by forcing votes back onto Redd I was pissing off the mafia, but it’s looking less likely that is the case based on how this played out.
Weepel comes in and puts everyone on blast for being mafia, except Kane Warhead at this point which is kind of funny under the circumstances. Since Kane wasn’t named here it’s probably not a valid list that set him off, but I had to mention it because otherwise people would just say I ignored this post because I was accused in it.
Black Jesus comes in and posts a bunch of retorts to previous posts in favor of lynching redd, and calls out Orochi, Weepel and GCL for ignoring some of the posts and blindly clinging to others.
Immediately afer this post, Kane throws in the town claiming the civilians have it too easy because SOMEBODY apparently has the witness role (the role that lets one civilian know all the mafia from the start of the game).
I don’t want to get into any mud slinging about what I personally think currently, since our vote is locked for now and we have to survive a mob hit before we can press on, but I wanted to make this post BEFORE the mafia have the chance to kill me so that if I do die at least the rest of the civilians won’t overlook this HUGE clue
bleh, I edited it to fix spelling and theres still more spelling errors : / I didnt want to edit it again just to cause more people to freak out I’m editing contents of my posts
Clearly I meant threw in the towel, not town
Also theres irony in the fact my reason for editing “Spelling fixes” had spelling errors on its own
It’s funny that people freak out when we edit posts, after all this is a game and we need to be careful of what we’re saying.
exactly, so if you aren’t careful that’s your fault. part of the game, unless you revealed something that you aren’t allowed to reveal, which i’m sure nobody did cause we aren’t that stupid.