SWbeta obviously didn’t know he was banned. You’re not helping you or your boy GCL.
EDIT: Wait. So was Kane mafia or civilian? He gets to say since he quit, right?
based on what his wording it seems he was mafia, why would a civi be upset about a witness role.
That depends. What does the witness do again? :lol:
Edit: I thought there were only medics and secret police?
i don’t think it would be that gamebreaking as then the mafia could assign one person to act like a witness and create doubt, but some people don’t like to have any fun :S…
Although i guess it’s possible warhead could have been the witness and not liked it as i can see being a witness and being called a mafia for it would make some people butt hurt haha.
Damn, this threads been blowing up overnight.
Theres other secret roles that are usually revealed as the game goes on, but what they are is unknown; that’s why they’re secret. I think the only ones that are guaranteed for each game is Medic and Undercover Police, but even then I’m not sure if they’re really there; it would be awesome to ask for the medic and undercover to PM your requests even though they don’t exist just to throw us off.
Besides, it doesn’t take a witness to understand just how stupid the mafia is playing this one, stop trying to blame your ineptitude on the game and ruin it for the rest of us
Not Part of the game
Spoiler
You know I was the witness last game right? And you know the civilans still lost right? How was it broken? Your loss. Sorry you feel that way.
This is my theory. If we lynch RedD now it’s buying us time to see how people react. He is going to get the boot due to inactivity anyways so now we got to see some theories and some speculation without wasting a life technically.
I agree…I’m voting RedD.
voting is closed lol…
oh wow. my bad lol…
Voting isn’t closed, it’s only if you’ve ALREADY voted you can’t change your vote. Theres still technically 48 hours left to get votes in.
oh i misunderstood the rules muh bad…
Good game everyone. It’s going a lot faster than the last one. Thanks for playing.
lol seriously.
Ok, putting my vote back on RedD. Going strictly with the majority this time.
/at work so can’t post much.
Pimp Willy, voting is actually close. since we are not allowed to change our votes once they are cast and there’s only a couple of people left. those votes won’t actually make more the votes need to lynch ** supreme jd**.that’s what i’m getting from the post the game master made.
we just lost our first civilian, but seeing how ** kane_warhead** is offically kicking himself out the game. he’s state of paranoia over a “witness” in this game confrims that he is an actual mafia member along with ** supreme jd**. the only people who would be so scared about that are mafia members and he’s the only one who is bringing the whole “witness” ordeal back into this game. since you’re out of the game, why don’t you tell us your role, or do you want us to lynch you next round or wait for the game master to kill you this round to prove that you’re a mafia member?
- i’m prefectly fine with lynching you next round since you’re going to be inactive a la redd ~
yes clearly JD is a mafia member because Kane warhead quit the game 
This is whack. You really gonna ruin the game for 23 other people? I would have rather been right based on my godlike intuition than to have it verified by a QUITTER. Don’t cry on the first round, jeez…and even if you wanted to, you should have addressed those issues before the game started. It was entirely possible to do so. This reeks of corny…:bluu:
RedD being banned isn’t the most cut and dry factor in all of this, as referenced by our creative uses of his disappearance. In fact, his silence is speaking volumes about the identities of a good handful of y’all…once again, just to re-iterate: having an inactive player serves the CIVILIANS for the majority of the time. The only way an inactive player can contribute to the downfall of the civilians is to not be present to make that tie-breaker vote; in any other situation, inactives are great.
If an inactive is Mafia, would you want to get rid of him? Sure, but HE CAN WAIT. We gain nothing if we kill 5 mafia and let the last one kill all of us in the end. This isn’t like fighting a hydra; we don’t get bonus points for killing anything but all of the mafia. The fact that he’s banned and isn’t available to try and sway people’s minds is a BENEFIT.
It makes total sense, which is why the mafia totally screwed this game up. They targeted him AND tried to introduce the irrelevant argument about his annoying habits right off the bat, trying to get the rest of us to vote with reasons irrelevant to the game. What sucks is that this is SRK and pure logic isn’t gonna cut it for most of the sheep; someone has to lead the charge with clever metaphors and creative moments. But if you care to take a look at the posts of the past, it is quite obvious who some of the mafia are.
It just sucks that so many people already voted for RedD this round; unless SWBeta comes out to try and fix some of the chaos, he’s pretty much gone. Waste of a vote. I, too, have my own issues with some of the rules of the game…but I’m not gonna quit like a baby. :arazz:
I think I came to the opposite conclusion as you Weepel, you seem to be under the assumption the mafia is the one targetting redd, to me it seems the opposite, they’re trying too hard to protect their own. Why would the mafia be targetting an inactive? Like you said it makes no sense.
The only way it makes sense to me is if the Mafia tried to protect their own out of the gate before realizing it was better to cut off the infected limb rather than try to salvage it. It’s pretty clear cut to me who some of the mafia are, but apparently that list is quite different to you.
Either I’m completely reading things the wrong way, you’re mafia trying to confuse people again, or the situation isn’t as clear cut as it seems in my head. Of course, this all depends on if redd ends up being mafia or not, but I’m pretty sure he is going to be just seeing how this all played out. If he’s not, well then I’d have to look pretty hard at what went down again
I dont see how Redd is such a big deal.
Shouts out to Kane! thanks for wasting my vote, you jackass!
kane_warhead has quit the game so he commits suicide. Players who quit the game will not be allowed to make a final post. I am a bit disappointed that he quit so early in the game.
Because the game is still in the early stages, I will not be revealing his or RedD’s roles, because I just found out that he was banned when I posted up the tallies last night.