A ‘better’ discussion? Capcom isn’t going to read this at all.
And fuck ‘should,’ Capcom will go with the exact same plan. It’ll be individual characters for download (or possibly pairs, but I doubt this), and everybody else gets a mandatory update patch so that we can play against them. We will all download the characters, we will pay to be able to choose them. If it makes you feel better, you can call the eventual “buy a bunch of characters at once” option an ‘expansion.’
People keep bringing up stuff like, “but what if we could choose!” and “what if it was all, like, $1!” Really? It won’t happen.
The only good side to this, from a competitive point of view, is that Capcom isn’t going to go the Freemium/Farmville route and start selling Sentinel for $80. “Hey, it’s your choice! You don’t have to buy him.” stomp stomp stomp stomp The clear effect of DLC characters for a fighting game is that those who want to compete will have to pay more money for a complete roster, and tournament organizers will be inconvenienced. The amount extra they will have to pay is most likely going to be in the $10 - $40 range, and probably in the middle of that range.
If you are posting here that you are in favor of DLC because maybe you can get Ghost Rider, and you looove Ghost Rider, what are you even doing here. This is a board for fans of fighting games, not marvel characters. I just don’t get it.
I also reject that 'like everything else, you get to choose whether to buy it or not. If you like it, buy it; if not, don’t." Because while it is true, it is trivially so. That part is obvious, and it should not even be part of the discussion. People are discussing what they would like and what they would not like, and some people are saying they would like to buy a game with no DLC available for it. It is not something that Capcom is going to sell to us, but as long as we’re discussing what would make a better game, it’s reasonable to ask for.
If your position is the more reasonable ‘why are we having this discussion when it’s already been decided,’ well, OK. But then you don’t need to post here, right?
EDIT: RARRRGH