RESURRECTION!
Interesting idea on the hybrid stick. My first instinct was “crazy talk” - but I play on a hitbox, so I’m a fan of crazy stuff.
Personally, me likely hitbox for Zangief. But I’d be highly intrigued to see how a stick/analog stick would work. There’d have some way to deal with opposing inputs. The player would have to get accustomed to letting one go to neutral before activating the other. If someone wants to work up a prototype, I’d be interested to see if it works. Till then, I’ll be doing tachi-720s on my hitbox.
The more I think about it, though…for my part, there’s nothing that you said that can’t be done with a hitbox or even a stick. I posted a video a while back of a walking 720 (like Hayao does often - not truely standing, but 720 -> walk forward -> press button), and a tiger knee-U2. It’s not fantastic quality, but it’s done with a stick.
These days I’m on a hitbox and I’m more experienced, and even more precise with inputs. I do love the way Vangief buffers SPD into his footsies, though. His technique can be done on a stick, but it’s way easier on an analog pad.