Anti-Decapre arguments:
- People may have expected a character which was at the same time totally new and interesting. Something of Juri’s calibre. Something we haven’t had since 2010.
- Her in-game colors look a little bit off.
That’s all I could find.
Pro-Decapre arguments:
- She looks cool, fun and interesting.
Which sounds way more important to me than the “anti” arguments and at least as objective as the “There were a million other better candidates for the 5th.” of the OP.
I understand that, but people don’t seem to realize that Capcom was screwed anyway. Because when they announced the first four characters, they probably had nothing concrete to show about Decapre.
What do you think would have happened if they had announced the character with only unfinished artwork to show for months ? The reaction would have been basically the same, only for different reasons.
The crowd would have been like "Booh Crapcom, why do you tease us with some shitty artwork and then show us nothing for months ? We want to see some gameplay already, you stupid trolls!"
And, no, showing early buggy gameplay when it has not even been finalized on paper would not have been a good idea. In fact, showing your whole creative process to the crowd is almost never a good idea.
They picked their poison, and I don’t think we can ultimately blame them for that.
Come on, I’d bet you are smarter than that. And you know it is way more subtle than that.
It also means that you cannot go into reversal “cannon spike” (not sure if she has a move like that, but whatever) after a blocked jump in or crossup, that you cannot do FADC into special, that you cannot walk forward and do light ~ medium x special, and many other restrictions like that. You WILL have to play differently (and sometimes, I would even say “smarter”) on plenty of occasions.
Capcom fired the staff members responsible for restraining Ono from trolling. They were too expensive, and, in all honesty, not too good at their job anyway.
So basically, what you are saying is “People who hate her are butthurts, people who love her are kids, but I am okay because I don’t care and I am neutral.” ?
Why would they remove her now ? I can understand that you would rather have seen Capcom focusing on other things than Decapre, but now that she is nearly done anyway, why would anyone want her removed, except out of pure hate ?
Probably. But then you would have to remove a good portion of the existing cast. Because the level of “stupidness” in this game is quite high already.
Guile spamming Sonic Booms.
Dhalsim spending the whole match to flee from the opponent while hitting them from five meters away.
Dive kick characters being all happy about their dive kicks.
Blanka … well, being Blanka.
And I am not even talking about Rufus here. As a Claw player, during several minutes after every Rufus encounter, my ears cannot send to my brain anything else than “Ay ay ay ay ay ay …”.
Heck, I would even say that my character is stupid. Fighting with a claw, really ?
But is all this “stupidness” a bad thing in a game like Street Fighter ? Not necessarily.
Now, maybe you see something particularly retarded about Decapre that other characters don’t exhibit, but then you should explain your view.