I just finished Shadow of the Tomb Raider yesterday.
Main campaign took 14 hrs approx.
Pros:
Great environmental graphics and design of the areas
Fun puzzles and platforming sections
The flashback level was a nice change of pace.
Final boss battle
Cons
IMO, The amount of combat relative to platforming/explorations is probably the least compared to TR 2013 and Rise of TR. Id say this has 70 % exploration/jumping and 30 % action.
TR 2013 - 70 action/30 exploration
Rise of TR - almost 50/50
The controls are slightly worse compared to previous games. Changing between the different types of arrows used to be just pressing up IIRC and now its different.
The flashlight is automatically turned on by the game, but sometimes it is off when you really need it and on when you don’t
Compared to the previous ones, your carrying capacity is MUCH less esp for herbs and stuff.
There are sections in the game where you lose all your weapons and are forced to just do stealth kills for long stretches. Whats even funnier is that you are against military/mercenaries with big guns yet you cant use them even after defeating them.
I dont mind some stealth but its funny that there are 3 slots for firearms and you dont use them for long stretches of the game
–The melee combat through all three games is laughable. Most weapons are good for distance but in some times when they get close, you just have the ungainly axe swing that takes a long time to recover/
Most of the supporting characters are not memorable. I played TR 2013 then all 5 Uncharted games and then Rise and Shadow. Jonah is bland as fuck. Except for one Native american character, it’s the same with your other allies. Even the main villain has a big revelation about your past and it just falls flat. The second in command of the villains is built up to be a big threat/asshole in mid point and yet you dont EVEN fight him. Lame.
There are many options for skill tree leveling up but its funny bc so many are combat based and you barely do combat. You could just play through using only a few skill point upgrades.
I stll liked the game, but I didnt feel the same excitement. I really liked the previous two TR reboot games. I have never played the original 90’s-2000 games so I cant compare.
I think they should wait a bit and retool their ideas before doing another game
Overall: 7.5/10