I would also put Sagat in second tier.
A2 Rose has too many options. Good AC (grabs pretty much everything, with good timingā¦you can grab people out of supers, out of the air, etc and you can combo after it. Good normals, especially crouching Fierce (great anti-airā¦c.FP xx Level 1 throw super is like 30% damage) and crouching Strong.
CCs are OK, though not great. Fireball super can be used as anti-air, though the throw super beats pretty much everything anyway, even early. Shadow super (Soul Illusion) does buff damage, great block damage, and has safe unblockables. Can also be used vs jump ins (Soul Illusion ->slide, though people may stop jumping at you after you hit them with c.FP xx super a few times).
Has Soul Reflect vs fireballs, which means she can build meter REALLY quickly, and also gets some tricks likeā¦if Ryu is halfway across the screen and throws a fireball, you use medium Soul Reflect to send it back at him, he throws another one (either out of habit or to counter the one you sent back), you CC while the fireballs cancel each other out. Level 1/2 reflect supers are nice to have vs fireballs (level 2 beats everything), and the Level 3 soul throw super is obviously insane. Also has her own fireball, which pushes her back when she does itā¦ie. someone is too close, you do crouching Forward xx SP fireball, youāre now further away from them, if thatās where you want to be.
Crouching Strong being so good allows you to cancel from it. Example, crouching SP xx Soul illusion, sweep -> crossup -> whatever (this can actually be done after an AC, like most of her combos).
Itās not really one big thing that she has, but she has a little bit of everything. Has a few issues vs Zangief and some other characters, but sheās clearly pretty damn good.