First and foremost, tier lists in team games is stupid in general; unless we’re talking about one extremely unbalanced game. Yeah… yall know what game I’m hinting at too. But as far as silly tier lists go, this one is pretty screwed up.
Phoenix -> Cannot be tier ranked, period. The problem here is that while she has the POTENTIAL to be the most devastating character in the game, she is also the only character in the game that dies to any “complete” basic combo. She will always have to have her own tier pretty much… though to be honest I’d say she shares one with Wesker. And if you do want to pair her into one, she wouldn’t get past A-tier for the aforementioned reason.
Dante -> S tier for a character that has to do execution-heavy combos just to do the damage other characters do without trying? Not to mention I’m not positive any character in the game, overall, has slower normals than Dante. If Dante didn’t have his range, dare I say he’d be ass, and I’m saying this with him being one of my day one characters. Dante would be A-tier, max, and B-tier wouldn’t be the most ridiculous spot for him either.
Wesker -> S tier is debatable here. First of all, Wesker doesn’t hit very hard by himself. The very mechanics of his character make it near impossible to do more than around 700k on his own, unless you start a combo off a counter. Wesker is one of those characters who either moves up or down on tier placement based on his surrounding team. Not to mention, as good as Wesker is, he can be zoned out pretty handily on some occasions. However, because tier lists are moreso on solo character merit, he’s an A-tier character imo.
Amaterasu -> How you managed to place THE most versatile character in the game in A-tier while placing Dante in S-tier is absolutely perplexing. Amaterasu is an EASY S tier placement because she has to tools to do EVERYTHING herself. She has the potential to 1 hit kill the entire cast w/o help, she’s one of the fastest characters, she has great mobility, she has great rushdown and zoning options, she has a full screen punish, she can both start and finish DHC glitch combos, she has counters, and she’s the worst matchup for MULTIPLE characters. Even characters that don’t have any true “bad” matchups have issues with her (Wesker and Magneto, for example). And as I mentioned earlier, tier lists are based on single character merit. If there’s any character that is definitively an S-tier placement, it’s Amaterasu.
Dormammu -> As much as I love Dorm, he’s a B-tier placement at most. First of all, in an extremely heavy offense-based game, his weakness is rushdown. Secondly, without X factor or assists, his damage output is extremely mediocre compared to several of the other characters in this game. His rushdown options are almost Tron-like. If he didn’t have 8 way dash, they would be Tron-like. To top it off, he isn’t very fast, and he’s a huge target.
Taskmaster -> I won’t put up a huge argument for his placement in A-tier, but I do feel like he probably belongs more in B-tier for the simple fact that getting in with him can prove difficult. He has great damage output and health, but you’ll often see that if he doesn’t kill his target if and when he does get in, his target usually kills him first. He’s also got some bad matchups against a few of the more-used characters in the game.
Ryu -> I don’t know where you get the idea that the most “average” character in the game is in the bottom tier. There’s no reason for him to be place with the likes of Thor and Jill. He has good health, he can punish full screen at multiple angles. He can hit hard. He has a projectile assist. While he isn’t the best, he certainly isn’t the worst, and is a miserable candidate for the bottom tier. He certainly isn’t in a lesser tier than “assist characters” like Haggar and Tron. And he damn sure isn’t in a lower tier than MODOK or Captain America. He doesn’t “take alot of work” either. Hell… he even has arguably the easiest mission mode in the game. EVERYONE can do SOMETHING with Ryu. Easy C-tier placement.
Chun-Li -> Pretty much the same argument here as Ryu. Chun-li is not reasonably unusable, which is what being in the bottom tier generally entails. She’s a great lockdown assist character and also has great x-factor potential. And again, she certainly isn’t in a lesser tier than MODOK and Captain America. C -Tier
M.O.D.O.K -> MODOK doesn’t have an particularly great assists, and while he can be annoying, he’s pretty much the definition of what you described as a D-tier character (he’s difficult to do good damage with compared to the rest of the cast). D-tier placement.
Captain America -> Same as MODOK. The definition of a D-tier character by your explanation of it.
X-23 -> I’ve got nothing against X-23 as a character. In fact I’ve off and on considered maining her. But I see no reason that she isn’t a C-tier placement. Her health isn’t too great, she doesn’t have the trickiest of mixups if you comprehend her movements, her damage output isn’t that high, and she doesn’t have the best assists ever. She’s got her speed and “under the radar” factor going for her. C-Tier placement.
Iron Man -> Iron Man is exactly what you described as a C-Tier character. He’s also got rather strange hitboxes, and you generally see Iron Man (the few times he’s picked) spend alot more time dying than doing any actual fighting.
Deadpool -> Deadpool honestly needs his own tier in between B and C. There’s not a strong enough of an argument to put him in B-tier, yet there’s also not a strong enough counter argument for him to be in C tier. Either or is fine really, but I’d probably put him in C tier.
Super Skrull -> If you want to call B-tier the big sleeper category, you can’t leave out Super Skrull. He’s got very useful command grabs, his damage output is good, he’s got good health, he isn’t overly slow, it isn’t hard to do good damage with him… there’s really not much against him besides potential matchup issues. Even so, that’s not enough to overshadow his strong points. Also, depending on how long you’ve been following Marvel, you may or may not have seen that Super Skrull was one of the original annoying characters pre-release. By that I mean, before everyone was picking Sentinel, everyone was picking Super Skrull. The other used-to-death character was Deadpool.
Felicia -> Free unblockables… only argument needed to keep her out of the bottom tier. C-Tier placement.
C. Viper -> Same as Skrull here. If B-tier is the sleeper category, C. Viper has to be in it. She can punish ALOT of things other characters can only block against. She’s got great options for zoning or playing rushdown. She builds meter well, and can be useful building it for later characters as well as using it for herself. Her execution is definitely of the heavier variety, but it’s not so difficult that she can’t be a B-tier placement.
Akuma -> Another tricky placement. His health and somewhat lack of options for getting in safely w/o an assist puts him in B-tier. His X factor potential and assist put him in A tier. Though he’s my favorite fighting character of all time, he’s a high B tier placement.
With all that said… imo, despite tier lists for team games being generally retarded, if one had to exist it would presently be (Listed in order of rank within the tiers as well)
S-Tier
[LIST]
[]Wolverine
[]Magneto
[]Amaterasu
[/LIST]
A-Tier
[LIST]
[]Phoenix
[]Wesker
[/LIST]
A-Tier
[LIST]
[]She Hulk
[]Zero
[]Dante
[]Sentinel
[/LIST]
B-Tier
[LIST]
[]Akuma
[]Taskmaster
[]Dormammu
[]Storm
[]C. Viper
[]Trish
[]Doctor Doom
[]Spencer
[]Spider Man
[]Super Skrull
[/LIST]
C-Tier
[LIST]
[]Deadpool
[]Tron
[]Iron Man
[]X-23
[]Ryu
[]Hulk
[]Chris
[]Felicia
[]Shuma Gorath
[]Chun-Li
[]Morrigan
[]Haggar
[/LIST]
D-Tier
[LIST]
[]Jill
[]Viewtiful Joe
[]Arthur
[]Thor
[]M.O.D.O.K
[]Captain America
[*]Hsien-Ko
[/LIST]
Some of those are interchangeable for their spots 1 up or 1 down… I just didn’t feel like making a bunch of arrows to notate it. Also, C-tier could DEFINITELY start with Spider Man. If it weren’t for his insta-kill Phoenix tech, C-tier would start with him.