I recognize and agree with your points. In retrospect, I’d say the matchup is even at worst. I wouldn’t call it a losing matchup but it certainly is one with little room for error on Rose’s part; she needs to be on point and maintain excellent spacing nearly all the game. If you want to see the matchup numbers changed in Rose’s favor, sure, you’re welcome to it. I don’t care since I don’t place much stock in matchup numbers, reason being I don’t feel numbers can actually capture the dynamic of the matchup. Rose-Hawk might be 6-4 at footsies range but when Hawk gets in on Rose it might as well be 3-7. Its hard to quantify that and I feel it’d be far more valuable for the focus of the guide to be on explaining in depth what each character’s options, strategies, etc. are in the matchups.
That aside, in the future if you’re going to make a controversial claim like “Rose beats Hawk. I disagree with the matchup 4.5-5.5. 6-4 Rose.” you might as well wait until you can write a full argument supporting it before throwing it out there. Prevents a lot of people (such as myself) from getting the wrong idea. SRK got plenty of keyboard warriors thinking they know the ins and outs of the game better than anyone else. I should’ve known better since I’ve been around the Rose section for a while to know you’re fairly knowledeable but to prevent future misunderstandings with others, please don’t throw shit out there without backing it up.