I agree 10%, which is why I wish to tread lightly. BUT, remember that this is not a new plan. It’s the same plan that we’ve been on for a bit now. Except the only thing is that Saitsu came up clean. This is the old plan, the only thing to consider is whether or not we go through with it.
What would that buy me? Besides this lynching that I’m about to get.
I actually submitted that as a possibility myself.
Not 100% the same but yes I would be in agreement with that only if we KNOW that we’re not going to give up another kill. **please correct me if I’m wrong here, but I read earlier that we’re only two civilians away from loosing. ** Is that true? My urgency is brought on because of that. If we can eat a civilian death, then sure, lynch me right now.
read more closely about where my “suspicion” lies.
I already answered that. Saitsu.
I threw you under the bus in jest mostly, but with the realization that in this game jesting is taken quite seriously. Also, I posted my suspicions of you and my reasons for it earlier. Annnd I definitely agree with you that GR has lived too long. But keep in mind that we’re using Azure’s plan, not mine, and giving GR the fenix down this late in the process is just maddening.
LOL I can’t say that I blame you.
Godots Revenge is dancing right now. But he won’t be dancing for long.
Lynch:Manx I’ll be changing this as soon as I see a way out. :tup:
I’ll leave now,
I have nothing left to analyze,
My suspects are more or less the same as it was on Day 2, so I’ll refrain from restating the points I’ve made.
Lynch The Co-Jones
Day 3, he’s the only one that has yet to post.
Hopefully, you guys don’t let him slip under the radar.
That said, this thread feels so gloomy with the vocal players.
*I was completely wiped out yesterday, but really? Only 9 posts overnight? Because we don’t have a Alpha dog, has this thread really degenerated to THIS? I’am beside myself right now. We needed people to step up, and since no one has yet to do so, I’ll try stepping up to the best of my abilities.
*I’m really looking at Manx’s lynch to vote himself and scratching my head. Either he is a mafia member throwing his hands up in the air as he pities the poor job we’ve been doing as civs. Or he is a Civ who is throwing himself on the sword to remove a confusing element as the game heads into a lynch or lose situation. These are the two possibilities I’ve come to as of now. *
*The first quote in my previous post show’s that he SAID he would have recruited Neesa but he easily throws her under the bus. I forgot to quote the two posts Manx posted at top of page 11 where he did point the finger at Neesa. *
@Manx: when I posted the idea of lynching you first, and then GR, it’s not essentially the same as your plan of reversing that order. It changes the numbers significantly, and very much in our favor if you are indeed mafia.
Rest of the thread: realize that Manx went from requesting medic protection overnight to offering himself up as a lynch target. That’s a pretty big swing. He adopted the actual civ mentality of “I can die, it’s fine” a little too late… only after he really thought it through. It’s a really suspicious move.
If you need further convincing, look no further than the extremely skilled Synonym. Even as he was a strong contributor to our cause, he didn’t do anything to make himself a less attractive target, and subtly hinted that he might be medic as he mentioned in his LG. He did that to protect the medic, even knowing he’d be out. Manx has done the opposite, and posted a smoke screen to get himself out of it.
*He’s one of the most experienced players in this game with 3 prior games under his belt. If he’s spy then someone trusted his abilities avoiding the noose while being a adapt partner at casting suspicion. Or alternatively they had faith in Manx to fulfill a role in their master plan. Or they simply thought they’d have synergy together.
If Manx is Hale then he recruited someone and the only person he said he’d recruit would be Neesa. But that doesn’t necessarily mean he was being honest. If he recruited someone other than Neesa then it’s possible he was planning to throw her under the bus eventually when his side needed to. Now that I think about it, he doesn’t even have to be Hale to use that sort of tactic. If he did recruit someone then everyone who voted for him should be thinking preemptively about who would he take over Neesa and why. *
The reason I asked for protection was because as soon as GD comes up mafia I’d be toast to them without protection IF, and only if they don’t know who medic is. After that, it’s pretty much GG unless the Medic guesses right 100% every night after tomorrow night.
That’s why. In fact, unless we get a Mafia kill it is pretty much GG.
After today we will look like this:
The Co-Jones
DarkGeneral
GodotsRevenge Manx
Mobius
Neesa
Pietastic
Two of which are Mafia. Then during the night phase this will occur:
The Co-Jones
DarkGeneral
GodotsRevenge Manx
Mobius
Neesa
Pietastic
Assuming, of course that our Medic is unable to guess correctly/ we bait them and make a save. Leaving us with:
DarkGeneral
GodotsRevenge
Mobius
Neesa
Pietastic
Two of which are mafia. There can’t be a tie unless medic guesses right 100%. Mafia can’t force a lynch either.
*Why? Why would you change your vote if he’s #2 on your list? Someone (or someones) changing their vote from Manx to someone else doesn’t necessarily equate to the new target being someone you’re willing to lynch over Manx. In fact isn’t it kind of counter intuitive if Manx is your #2? Why do you want to lynch The Co-Jones so badly? *
So, rather than debunk this all point by point, I guess I’ll wait for you to do the same thing you did before, where you revise your argument when you realize which points don’t make sense…