InB4 the LG saying to lynch Manx. Boom.
The only notable thing is that I’m putting Manx up to 60% suspicion. Synonym’s been playing really well so far, and I respect his Last Gasp. But Co-Jones is still at the top of my list.
Hook up some stars for my man, Synonym. I really wanted him to stay in this game.
Lynching me won’t help you. I’m regular civ. I’m Red Scout #2.
I’m telling you, just listen to Syn and go after the other people in the “triumvirate of evil” Dark General, GODOTS!!! and The Co-Jones. I do not have my notes on me ATM, but as soon as I get to them I will post up my reasons as to why I think Dark General, Godots Revenge and Co-Jones need to be looked at. Here is a hint though, out of those three that need scrutiny, one of them we need to keep alive.
Pietastic I cannot get a read on and he is now our strongest player after Synonym got killed, so we really need to keep him. In fact, I’d say we need to keep him above all else for now.
Also, to clarify and hopefully get some heat off my back, the “secret” person I didn’t want to blame was Neesa. I been trying to stay buddy buddy with her so I can try baiting out differing responses, testing for loyalty, but she’s playing almost as tight a game (and making as many mistakes) as I am. She’s been pretty quiet otherwise, which is why I’ve been hinting at my suspicions towards her. It’s ALL THERE, if you go after my posts.
Like I said, lynching me isn’t going to help. A lot of this goes back to the very first lynch and night killing. Re-read, people. Subtract the people who post but don’t make meaningful comments. That’s why I don’t post a lot. If I can’t contribute or say something witty then I don’t see a need to even post. Where I have posted (other than jokes), there has been meaning in all of it. Just read over it and you’ll see. :tup:
Godots Revenge, Neesa, DarkGeneral, Mobius
Both Mafia are somewhere within this group.
My appeal to fellow civilians is to get Godots this lynch and watch Mafia kill me. Bet it. What have we got to lose? We still have medic somewhere (I just convinced myself why Synonym wasn’t protected last night) AND we’ve been saying GODOTS since the beginning of the game. Go back and look at the vote tallys (I’ll go cut/paste them in a bit) and see how he’s voted. Look at the record, look at the posts from the perspective of figuring out WHY Synonym was murdered last night. It was not only because he was our strongest player. Think more yomi. I can’t go out and say it, or else I risk outing our Medic.
Yes I am trying to save my ass here, but only as a precaution to losing another civilian. We have two left. Lynching Godots will get us the mafia we need so badly. I’m telling you guys, he’s been sitting there trying his best to get us to lynch our own Medic. Just look.
Day 2 Vote:
[details=Spoiler]
Saitsu: Synonym, Pietastic, DarkGeneral
GodotsRevenge : The Co-Jones
The Co-Jones: Mobius, GodotsRevenge
Manx: Saitsu
Did Not Vote: Manx, Neesa[/details]
Day 1 Vote:
[details=Spoiler]
BullDancer : Azure, The Co-Jones, DarkGeneral, GodotsRevenge, Manx, Neesa, Pietastic, Saitsu
Azure: BullDancer, Mobius
Manx: Synonym[/details]
The day two votes were the most damning. Today’s vote will for sure reveal a mafia, regardless of who gets lynched. There’s absolutely no way around it. Look at those votes with respect to what’s already been said and keep in mind that The Mafia know that they cannot reveal who they plan on killing to The Medic and you will see a pattern start emerging that revolves around Godots Revenge.
Lynch: Godots Revenge
Used the wrong button.
Lynch: Godots Revenge
You’re red scout #2? Is this because you picked a role to die as, should you not be so fortunate as to live through the whole game? I didn’t pick a role.
I don’t understand the significance of picking a role, but yep. That’s the one I picked. :tup:
I’m not picking up what you’re putting down. You might as well be explicit, so long as you don’t cast light on who the medic might be. If you post vague hints and expect us to interpret them, the civs and mafia alike are able to interpret them. There’s a risk there.
Are you suggesting a “decision ladder” where we lynch GR, and then Co-Jones if he ends up clean?
That will work. In fact, if you’re good with that then I am. :tup:
Or if you really want to badly enough you can Lynch ME afterwards. That’s how sure I am that Godots = Mafia.
@Pietastic I’m going to pick it up from now on,
[quote="Mobius;8409030"Pietastic makes a good case, hyper-posting is as damning as wallflowering.I looked back and noticed I was a perpetrator of the said offense, so I’ll keep what I feel are unnecessary posts to myself.[/quote]
I’ve mentioned this in page 3, like you, I was trying to keep the signal-to-noise ratio down.
Me and Synonym chatting about our previous game did not really do anyone any good.
As for Manx, you’re saying we go through with Azure’s plans, yes?
Lynch Bulldancer, if he turns up clean, then Saitsu and Godots must be mafia.
If Saitsu turns up clean, then Godots must be mafia.
Don’t worry, I’m beginning to think less that you’re mafia at the moment.
Setting yourself up for Day 4 lynch is quite a risky tactic for a mafia to employ.
That is, unless, you know that you’re partner is unlynchable during the day.
Yes, the Azure thing that we should have done from the start. I know caution and what not, but it’s pretty obvious now. :tup:
Actually we kinda are doing it now. So… continue with that same plan. Lynch: Godots Revenge.
Yes, they do, don’t they?
About this, Manx, you’re setting yourself up to be lynched on Day 4 as you go through with that procedural plan. If you’re mafia, taking out 3 civilians is quite a feat in an eleven man game.
With 1 mafia left, his chances are slim.
But, what if the mafia decided that 'tis a fine trade?
1 carries out the plan to take out three targets, whilst the other throws him under the bus by casting suspicions on him as early as Day 2.
Once the plan is fulfilled, if the other mafia lynches the one who carried out the said plan on Day 4, it would cement his status as a civ which would make future days smooth sailing.
That said, the pairing in my mind would be Manx and Pietastic.
Other than that, I see no reasons that would convince me that those two are mafia.
Manx missing the vote is still messing with my mind though.
That should be easy to sort if you’re truly seeing something sinister at play. You approach it first from the perspective of me trying to alter the votes. Then form the perspective of me truly making a simple mistake. Which ever seems more likely given the circumstances is most likely to be the truth. Given what you’ve said already, which do you believe? :tup:
Oh, and I also want to point out that if I’m wrong, we’re likely to lose the game. So everyone please discuss this seriously. Godots should be in here defending himself rather quickly.
If we lynch him and he turns up town and mafia successfully get a kill during the night phase, we’re fucked. If we lynch him, he turns up town and then you lynch me the next day, we’re fucked even if Medic protects the night target.
So, yeah. Put some thought into this guys. :tup:
Also, since this is pretty much my plan now I’m going to go over it in my head from Mafia’s perspective to see if there are any obvious flaws while I go pick up my kids. You guys just focus on the previous bits.
So far, I already thought of these:
Flaw #1: If mafia knows who the Medic is (And I believe they do): We’re fucked unless Godots is scum and we play perfectly thereafter.
Flaw #2: If Mafia doesn’t know who the Medic is, then Medic has to trust me and protect me from lynching, creating a yomi situation where Medic and Mafia have a guessing game over who’s going to be night targeted after we Lynch Godots. At that point they could effectively off us 1 by 1.
That’s just what comes to mind in these few minutes. I’m leaving now. Let me know if this is all sound or not, because I’m working under the understanding that we’ve only got two self-lynches left, max.