SRK Mafia XVIII: Phoenix Wright - Back in Session -- Turnabout Icege (GAME OVER -- CIVILIANS WIN!)

I always seem to suspect Syn but for some reason less so this game. I didn’t like how he seemed to be pushing a suspect I chose in such a subtle manner

DG no read on. People are paranoid from last game

MP can we have a new update on the tally please, your last post is 7hrs old.

Omg, I was mentioned. Thank you~ I’ve been playing in another game where I’m now dead so I can start focusing here more.

I think crucades and RT are civilians.

TGG, too. I’m of the opinion that MP would have DQ’d him for that edit if he was Mafia to keep everyone from complaining.

I dunno why some people think DarkGeneral is dirty. I got a civilian vibe from the few posts that DukeC made.

Synonym is probably clean because of a particular thing he said. It’s not concrete at all, but it’s something I’ve said a few times as a civilian myself because I had nothing to hide. And don’t suck up to me this time, Synonym, or I’ll change my mind.

I think I’ll withdraw my initial suspicion of Vynce for now. He’s being rather aggressive - something I don’t associate with his Mafia behaviour - but even he himself said that he changes his playstyle up, so I dunno.

I don’t know who this Pimp Willy guy is. I’m going to ignore him.

oz is dirty because we all know that Synonym guns for him when he’s clean and it hasn’t happened yet.

Anyway,

ForgeDigger has been playing wonky all game. It’s not a secret that she was one of the biggest protesters of the wallflowering that occurred last game. Thing is, she leans towards wallflowering when she’s Mafia. The theory is that if she’s Mafia, she can’t really do that this game after condemning it the previous one without potentially raising eyebrows. So she’s trying to post anything she can to keep herself from wallflowering. But the posts have been sloppy and she’s jumping on the flimsiest of things. Not to mention anyone - civilian or Mafia - can create that list of the current game history she’s been doing. It’s an easy way to make it seem like you’re helping out.

Hecatomb so far has reminded me of Mafia Hecatomb in the SoA game. That’s really all I have.

Alpha, I’m going to agree with Bious and Vynce that there’s seemingly something off with you.

Of those three, it’d probably be wiser to lynch Hecatom first because he’s had interaction with the other two (Forge and AC have had little with each other) and it could give more information. But… it’s Day 2. You can’t escape it, Alpha.

AlphaCommando is guilty.

I’m okay with DG having more time to prove himself to be his old, helpful self, I suppose.

Not reading Syn as dirty. Just wanted to hear PW’s impression of him. Specifically his.

***AlohaCommando is GUILTY a ***

Finally catched up with the thread
@Augustus‌
My name is Hecatom without a b :confused:

I know.

I honestly didn’t expect the AC lynch train that’s going on now, hmmm maybe mafia knows they can dogpile on him and use me as a scapegoat since I was the first one to publicly say I was voting for AC. Fortunately while I am open minded to arguments that may sway my vote unlike Combo Knight and Augustus, I’m also not that easy to scare off so I’m sticking with AC.

In response to the UC talk, just wanted to say I didn’t realize the possibility of both UC’s investigating the same person, but if the idea is to make lists for both to avoid that I must ask what is the point? Unless both UC’s figure out a code to RC to each other secretly which I heavily advise against anyways for fear of mafia sniffing them out like they most likely did with medic. Like I said early on by day 3 or 4 the UC who gets 3-4 guilty verdicts in a row should assume he’s DUC.

I’m not on that list of 5 so therefore, your ruse to safeguard the strongest 5 civilians is not in earnest as you are leaving out OZ! I know you’re probably grinning while reading this lol anyways, about the information thing, #1 I thought your name was brought up a bunch of times day 1, but that was syn and RF stuff yup getting my aussies mixed up again and the other info I can gleam from your death 1 way or the other isn’t something I can explain until you’re dead you’re just going to have to trust me and I really really hope you do, but if not then I understand as I am definitely not a trust worthy player after that 1 fucking time I was mafia.

I think I know the other reason you may have said those 5 names that you claim to not have said to bious or anyone, if I’m right which I’m 50% sure I am then that’s actually pretty clever however, it’s just as likely you’re trying to save your ass and make me second guess myself which will start a domino effect on the other votes.

@Blindknagg‌ he sure did get awful defensive for the zero people talking about him.

@Augustus‌ don’t ruin my win percentage any more you ass.

@crucades‌ um, I was one of the people who first pressed forge. Not sure where I defended it deflected for her lol.

@others not sure of how meta this play is but one of the photos ac posted had “alpha commando is roleless” as the filename. More or less damning?

@Augustus If I seem like I’m not really helping out, what would you like me to do instead?

Same question applies to everyone else who suspects me.

Your theory isn’t a bad theory. It’s just wrong. You give me way too much credit. I would still wallflower if I were mafia because I’d be too afraid of posting something that would ultimately dig my own grave. Besides that, I don’t think any mafia team would be okay with how reckless I’ve been. And yes, I’m doing it on purpose. And yes, I would stop if I had a team that told me to.

@Synonym seems like a joke to me.

I don’t see what the others are seeing against Alpha, really.

@Vynce I dont know why you tagged me about an RC.

Btw my suspects:
Augustus
jasonC
Hecatom
Pimp Willy
Dark General

And that’s all I got, for now. Feel free to question me, I’m all for it. Meanwhile:

[PretendthisISBOLD]Dark General is guilty [PretendthisisUNBOLD]

I love how Augustus can be random as fuck and everyone still thinks he’s mafia :rofl:

@ForgeDigger‌ Good
@Synonym‌ More.

I’m not particularly sold on anyone of the wagons currently so my vote for now

Great Cow Lord is GUILTY

Alright well im back from shopping. All set to look my sunday best in the two weddings I have to attend. Also Vynce I know that feel. The entire store I was at today had nothing but screaming children with teen moms. Contemplated leaving until all those stupid fuckers left. By the way, why the fuck am I seeing Christmas stuff in the beginning of October?

Nothing has really come up to change my vote off of Icege. I still dont trust him. I dont really feel like the bandwagon for Alpha is rooted in anything solid unless I missed a post. Was monitoring through mobile fleetingly. My battery life is ass so I wasnt looking too hard.

Is nobody else really disturbed by this magical 18 hour flight?

Im impressed you saw that. I was on my phone before so saw no file names. But alas, there it is, Chun Lis booty in all its roleless glory. He picked the one file he knew people would click to enlarge lol.

I’m willing to give up a roleless AC, even knowing how strong of a civ asset he can be, to teach him a lesson and to get the ball rolling. Be interesting to see how he actually picked up this momentum when I thought a lynch on him wasn’t really possible.

Agree, since my post on him was mostly a joke, but seeing now how there is a bandwagoon on him it is surely interesting

Only way I could see that is if dude has like a 4 stop flight to fucking Vietnam. I dont know where that came from either. Iwinalot inb4’d you with that point of interest though

Interesting, actually. He said he wouldn’t be back until after the deadline as well, which would put him at a 22 hour flight.

He’s also been active since he posted this. Hmm.

Well it looks like I’m going today, so when I flip Civ, it’d be for the benefit of the people that voted me to provide their justification before I die to not look suspect. It’s really in the voters’ best interest to provide justification beforehand.

It’s pretty clear that everyone else is playing with a different tactic to me. I’ve answered every question thrown at me and provided what insight I can, but people are still voting for me over less helpful players. It’s one of those situations where there’s seemingly nothing I can say or do to push the bandwagon off me. But yeah, as Synonym said, I’m roleless (fucking Dropbox got disabled from too much traffic), so voting for me isn’t going to lose you a role. And roles are the only important players in this game, right guys?

I may as well answer this while I’m here. The correct answer was yes. I was trying to influence the Corrupt in the list to keep the Civilians in the list alive for as long as possible. A strong Civ alive is more useful than taking an uninformed guess at a player in hopes that they’re Mafia. But the thread has shown that they’re willing to sacrifice strong players, so there’s no reason to try and keep these guys alive. You won’t be needing this, OZ.

I don’t learn lessons. Next game is a Day 1 lynch for RadicalFuzz regardless of the outcome of today. And you can’t stop me.

Well I think that summarises everything. Hecatom’s still not piquing any interest from anyone else, so I’ll join Aidebit.

IWinAlot is Guilty