That is too true, it really is a popularity contest, but if we can set our favoritism aside, whoever wins the match is the better player, IMO.
Even if 1 hit = KO, who will get that 1 hit? the better player? the worse player???
Some seem to say it is a crapshoot, that some mystical die will be rolled and it will decide who’s hit lands, and who gets spanked in that round.
Now, a first to 10? Just 10 dice rolls? I think we owe it more credit than that. Pick any other game that you consider not to be “1 hit kill” ST?, CvS2?, what is each round, other than a series of these “rolls of the dice”? The winner of each “roll” doesn’t win the round immediately, but he wins that roll, and executes whatever combo, and whoever wins more rolls per round, is the overall winner.
Seriously, pick any game, and show me how it doesn’t boil down to that, as long as both players have access to the same characters, moves, etc.
A players skill CAN, and WILL shift the “rolls” in his/her favor.
As far as close matches are concerned, winner takes all, 9 wins doesn’t get you much in a first to 10, you need that 10th win, those are the terms you agreed upon before starting the match. If you are scared of losing your champion title over a few rolls of the die, then don’t show up, it’s less gay than losing and claiming you’re better than the guy who beat you.