you don’t understand a fucking thing, it’s unreal how stubborn and ignorant you are.
your claims are simply ridiculous and unproven to say the least, plus you have absolutely no clue about how many cycles rubber contacts (of the quality seen in old joypads and low quality “fightsticks” ) can endure until failure, compared to the number of cycles and abuse some miniature snap micro switches, various mechanical keyboard switches etc can endure before failure.
Your experience seems , from what you’ve claimed, extremely limited to say the least.
In fact many name brand console joypads were notorious for failing rubber contacts that lost all resilience (hence not returning to neutral) …and playing for hours at home, yes even that, cannot compare the slightest to the abuse seen in arcades which is on a completely different level.
That’s when industrial grade parts come in the picture.
Even in the arcades there were some rubber based parts, way tougher than console parts but their very own nature was a problem still :
SF I cab had some pneumatic buttons but today you’d be lucky to find one in working state. Same thing for old rubber grommets used in the arcades, rubber at the time was prone to ozone cracking uv damage, drying out, etc and today most “NOS” parts are worth acquiring just for the sake of a collection, it is highly advised to use a repro fresh grommet instead of a cracked one.
As for the quality of the parts used in pads, they are naturally of a quality that wouldn’t last long enough if they were used in arcades. conductive rubber contacts loose their resilience with time, they even tear under repeated back and forth flexing or forceful playing, and sometimes being proprietary parts with specific dimensions etc they cannot be replaced easily whereas others can be but only for those who know where to buy said replacement rubber pads .
Stay respectful and start learning boy. It’s never too late. Heck I know some people who just started getting into old cabs with two way sticks or grommet based wicos and all that shit but know nothing about it, they felt the urge to pick up all the info they could it before it’s too late and get caught in some other matter . So what did they do? No they didn’t get on a forum insulting some guy trying to help, they simply ASKED QUESTIONS, tons of em and wrote things down on a list, which models, which brands, various tips and bits of advice etc. or else they’d be stuck in their project and it would never happen. They don’t have all the same goal, some want just to be period correct, others prefer reliability, some others don’t give a hoot and just stick in clone parts for a quick play on the cheapest possible cabinet, this has to be considered too.
Go see a pro arcade tech if there’s still one working next to where you live and repeat to him the crap you’ve told me and watch closely his reaction.