A couple people on the previous page wanted pics of the innards of the official Saturn USB pads, so I thought I’d bump this to share some. I snagged a USB pad and a PS2 pad from either NCSX or Play-Asia back when each of them were brand new, so I know mine are the genuine articles. Pics can be found here. I also still have the packaging for both SLS pads around here somewhere and could snap pics of those as well.
I snapped multiple pictures of three different controllers:
- black PS2 pad by SLS
- black USB pad by SLS
- white Japanese Saturn pad sold during the later years of the console’s lifespan
Most of the parts between all 3 controllers seem to be identical in shape and completely interchangeable, though I didn’t bother trying that out myself. Both of the SLS pads in particular are pretty much exactly the same except for the Start/Select buttons and PCB.
There are 2 noticeable differences between the SLS pads and the original Saturn pad. One is the plastic piece that the d-pad connects to. This piece is opaque and slightly more flexible on the original Saturn pad; the SLS pads have a solid white piece that is slightly more stiff. This doesn’t seem to affect gameplay at all. Even though I’ve been using all of these pads for a while, I just went ahead and booted Alpha 3 on MAME, went into the input test, and tried out a bunch of different motions (236, 623, 41236, 360, etc.) for testing. All of them register correctly and consistently. The only directional inputs I’ve never been able to reliably perform on these pads are stuff like quick 4646 or 2828 motions; I always seem to graze another cardinal direction when doing this, and it’s a problem that’s always been common to all 3 pads for me.
The other difference between the SLS pads and the original Saturn pad is the shoulder buttons, which is more obvious. The Saturn pad’s shoulder buttons are completely plastic and each rest against a switch on the PCB. The SLS pads have an extra rubber strip on the shoulder buttons which rest against a slightly smaller switch on the PCB. The shoulder buttons on the SLS pads feel like they have a bit more “spring” in them. At any rate, I can’t say that I’ve ever had a problem with dropped inputs or stuck buttons on any of these 3 pads, so this doesn’t seem to be a substantial difference either.
I also have a few other pads that I didn’t bother checking but could if anyone was really curious or something:
- gray Japanese Saturn pad sold during the console’s early years, made in Japan
- black American Saturn pads sold during the console’s later years, some made in Malaysia, others in China
Both look identical to the white pad. There’s subtle differences in the way they feel but that could just be from varying degrees of wear over the years, and none of them feel any more or less responsive than the others. The PCB on the white pad still has a 1994 stamp on it, so that at least seems to have not been changed over the course of the console’s lifespan.
I’ve seen some people in this thread report that their SLS pads have broken down or at least feel like they’re about to fall apart after less than half a year of regular use. I definitely don’t think that should be happening if you have the real thing. I’ve had my SLS pads well before SF4 came out and have used them regularly in addition to my original Saturn pads via USB converters every once in a while. I have yet to have a problem with any of them.