Being a big Capcom fighting arcade game collector, I love the passion on this thread:
What I’m getting from the responses is that there are generally two schools of styles of how to play fighting games: The “turtle style” and the “rushdown style”.
The word “turtle” is accepted now but it started as being a derogatory word for those players who waited and reacted to what the other players would do. Now it’s ok to call people turtles. It’s ok because they earned it. Right now, even though I see myself more so on the rushdown side, I could also see the point of view of turtle players also because I started off as one.
I’ve been playing in the Street Fighter So Cal arcade scene for most of my life ever since the original SF2 when I was a kid. As a kid I learned the game by being a turtle but as I played more a lot of people in the arcade frowned upon the turtle style. I got harassed constantly for being a turtle and generally it was looked upon many as a wimpy style of playing Street Fighter. So by the pressures of the arcade environment (Hey when you’re a little kid and you see teenagers get mad at you for being a turtle you get forced to change), I became more aggressive with my style of play and in fact I too started to frown upon people who turtle. They use to say in the arcade when someone turtled: “Attack that motherfucker”.
Turtle players today are kinda lucky that turtling in SF4 is accepted today. I mean to be good in this game you got to turtle.
But my point is, what was expected of me growing up playing I always had to be offensive. So the games like Alpha 3 that catered to the offensive players was a superior game then Alpha 2 which catered to the turtle players.
As of now since I like all Capcom fighting games, I really don’t care if people use the turtle or the rushdown style.
It’s a new world where turtling in SSF4 is more effective then rushing down so I can’t complain.
So as of today I believe that both the turtle style and the rushdown style are both honorable (for lack of a better term).
So to get to the point of the thread, I guess the better Vampire game is what type of style it caters to you most. But being a Capcom lover I always trusted how they made fighting games so I always choose the latest version of their game whether it be turtle or not. The latest version just always feels complete and balanced i.e ST, VS, A3, 3S, and MVC2.
When the VS series was getting popular, the style of fighting games was getting more rushdown oriented. I see 3S as a rushdown game (I own that arcade version too). When I play it, I just try to beatdown the guy as fast as I could.
Now with SSF4, the turtling is back in fashion so now the rushdown players have to adjust their game. And if you can’t adjust then just don’t play.
So whether you’re Team Turtle or Team Rushdown, it really doesn’t matter as long as you win. Because in the end that’s the point of all fighting games.
But I will admit, that turtling annoys the hell out of me because it feels like I’m doing all the work. But I don’t get mad at turtle players now because I realize that it’s part of the game and anything goes.
All is fair in love and war.