It’s funny how much I agree with that review, yet at the same time can’t bring myself to call Nier:Automata as perfect a game as he describes. Similarly to him, I was also pretty Nier obsessed when I was done with it, I just wanted to play it more (and I did), despite having done everything. I divulged every tiny scrap of knowledge I could from the game. No other video game has given me quite as much… I suppose, mental enjoyment. Yet I can’t ignore potential flaws in a game.
This guy however is what I am terming now as “lovingly biased” where he is still so high on the experience, that he’s unwilling to see flaws. I think the only thing in that video he even remotely hinted at being flawed is that you “might” get tired of killing machines. I agree with so much, yet the amount of gushing he made and the extreme statements in the video are a bit put-offish. Specifically, it is the line at 6:38 or so in the video which destroyed my enjoyment of the review, because it was such a bold statement, so much so, that it could only be said in ignorance. I will defend forever, that Nier Automata as a video game, within that medium, is one of the best constructed games, that utilizes the medium more than most other games. It uses gameplay well to help tell it’s story, aid in it’s philosophical messages, and really just uses the video game medium to full effect to tell a story which really only works great as a video game. However, I will NEVER make a statement so bold as to say that Nier is somehow one of the best things to come out of all media (coherent experience as he says). That’s… a crazy statement. I feel like statements like that can only be made in ignorance – how many stories have you read, seen or heard?
Am I wrong? Do you guys back a statement that glorious in strength? I love the game to death – but EVERY medium? I just – I just, I can’t handle statements like that, they get under my skin. A statement like that is essentially saying that all of these things I’ve never seen, all this music I’ve never heard, they CAN’T be better than what I just saw. Which is just ridiculous. Ugh… I just can’t – that’s just… too closed-minded a statement. If he had just limited it to Nier being really good at doing said things, that would have been fine, but to put words like “ever” in there, which includes so many things he’s never even seen – gah, it bugs me. You guys want to know what bugs me? There it is. Blanket statements like that.
I get he’s gushing, which is why I called him lovingly biased, but ugh… I’ve been gushing since I finished the game, and I’ve never gone that far. Maybe I’m just too open to improvement. As great as Nier is, it has flaws that could be improved. Maybe I’m weird.