If you want to discredit something because the author happens to have used kaillera, start with this, or don’t start at all. http://www.shoryuken.com/forums/showthread.php?t=70122
Now… On the topic of the online differences…
Mame allows you to assign multiple buttons to the same input. For instance, LP can be Y, ‘and’ T. What that means, is you can have your basic set of controls, and then other buttons that function as any number of your original controls, together, in the same frame.(I.E., 3P, 3K, Drill Claw, etc). Mame also has Auto-Fire support(Complete and utter bullshit waiting to happen. =/)
Kawaks, allows you to build macros that do that, advance to the next frame, and input another set of buttons, advance to the next frame, etc etc etc. So, you can map HaDouKen to a button. Or, alternatively, a Shinkuu Hadouken tiger knee’d as low to the ground as possible(Not that that matters in MvC, 'cause ryu sucks… But in XvsSF, Air Shinkuu Hadouken = fast as hell). I’m not sure if these macros work online(I know Mame’s do), so don’t assume they do. The macros have a limit, though… Something like 50 characters, including Advance Frame characters.
FBA, has your standard button layout, and then 3P, and 3K. That’s it. I always have, and always will, use old models of FBA. Optimized to run CPS2, even if the base program has problems dealing with lag(It sometimes resorts to frameskip. Solution? Don’t play on laggy servers. Too bad that’s not possible on kaillera these days.)
It’s unfortunate that these things are neccessary with most keyboards(Don’t get me wrong, you can buy KBs that are far more capable, and can support 2D Fighter input needs), but at the same time, they ‘are’ control enhancements.
Back in the day, there ‘were’ some big names on MvC Kaillera… Nibor played MvC a lot, and taught a lot of people a lot of things… But, even Nibor admits to it being a very different game online. Wolverine Dashing Infinite is ‘very’ hard on a cab. It’s insanely easier with a 3P button. WM flying inf is easier too(Once again, 3P button.) To this day, since MvC was emulated a long time ago, people play it like nuts on kaillera. It’s gotten 10 times more play online than it’s ever gotten offline. If Kaillera MvC hasn’t elevated to a seriously competitive, skilled field(Well, for MvC, anyway. xD)… I’d be ashamed of it. I wouldn’t be particularly surprised, though(Lag makes noobs of everybody.) But the fact is, the lag makes it a different game altogether. It’s not that j00 suck… It’s just that you’re playing a slightly different game…
Yeah, towards the end of when the snausage fingerz server was up(Note, I care about snausage because it was a paradise server. 56 user limit, and lag free. Completely. Run off a stable OC3. I don’t care about it because of the people that were on it.), and for most of fugu, I was the XvsSF best, but, I gave that up once I couldn’t play the way I’d learned to play anymore. All the current people on kaillera need to take a couple hours, and play offline, and realize, just what they’re missing.
Also… As long as no 3P etc macros were used… I think a KB vs Cabinet showdown would be totally fair. How the game was meant to be played is irrelevant… If a better method of control exists, it should be adopted, and become the norm. If KB isn’t better… Than let him play at his own disadvantage.
IMO… KB is better. 3P or no. But I’m a freak.