I didn’t want to respond because I responded to someone earlier about the same subject, but what the hell…
I think you’re kind of over exaggerating the decline of KOF in the US. You listed Frosty Faustings, and the two MLG events as examples. The first MLG event was a disaster that many people complained about because they announced it 3 weeks ahead of time giving no one time to save up and attend it. The next one in Cali was… bizarre. I’m not sure what happened. I thought for sure it would have a better turn out because of the SoCal and Norcal kof scene, but a lot of people were missing. To this day I’m not sure what happened. Either way, it was silly people didn’t attend when they could have and made the kof scene look bad. But for the most part, KOF has had solid attendance at major’s/regionals.
I wouldn’t call Frosty Faustings a major (no offense to Elvenshadow, it’s nice of him to throw the event every year for his region and for the guilty gear heads). It’s a regional, but it’s not an event top players flock to. It’s no surprise KOF had a low turn out. A better example of a solid turn out at a recent regional/major would be NEC where it had 57 entrants. Not spectacular like ssf4 or umvc3, but solid (P4 had a crazy turnout with over 100 which shocked me). I also think when EVO season starts rolling around you’ll see the turnout go up even more with players grinding it out.
So my point is, I think you’re exaggerating making it seem like KOF doesn’t get any sort of turnout at the bigger events, and citing the two MLG events and especially Frosty Faustings doesn’t really backup your point.
There’s something I’ve wanted to say about the MLG events for a while now and part of why I think it didn’t work out. When you attend a major, it’s more than just a bunch of tournaments for fg’s, I’d say it’s more of a celebration of fg’s. You walk around the hotel and everyone is talking about fg’s and carrying their arcade stick. You walk through the halls and every other door is left slightly open welcoming strangers to come in and play. You spend the whole weekend playing fg’s with anyone and everyone willing to play. It’s fighting game heaven for a weekend. I didn’t attend either MLG event, but as far as I could tell it didn’t have the same environment. If I have a limited budget and I have to decide whether to attend MLG or a major, why would I choose MLG where fg’s seemed to be a minor side attraction compared to a major where everyone is excited about fg’s.
Also, people in the fgc tend to play numerous games. So, for example, if I’ve been playing a lot of KOF through the weekend and just need to play something else for a bit, I can go to a friend’s room and play some sf4. In fact, a lot of KOF players play other games. Just in NYC, we have a number of players who play other fg’s such as Zidane (guilty gear and blazblue), a3religion (guilty gear), malik (melty blood), Liston (umvc3), chris g (this guy plays everything). As a player with a limited budget, I would prefer to go to an event where I’ll be able to see all my friends from all the different fg scenes as opposed to MLG.
Which brings up another point, and I think this is part of why MK did well at MLG. As far as I can tell, the MK community is a self sustained community (I hope that makes sense). What I mean is, for the most part their players seem focused on MK and MK alone. You don’t really see MK players playing other games. They are their own community. So whereas I would attend an event hoping to see all of my friends from different fgc’s, their friends are for the most part all within their own community. I should also mention that they, as a community, do a great job of going to as many events as they can to support their game.