It’s a different topic on the arcade environment versus talking about the business of running an arcade but you got a point here.
Staying at home and playing Capcom fighting games suck. So boring. I would even take it further that in a console gathering if there are too many set ups, it’s not as fun as well. It’s always good to have a crowd and a line around one set up. Not just for hanging out and talking, which is cool also, but if you have a lot of set ups and everyone is playing then you get a lot of poor quality matches all over. Not only that people are wasting energy on these poor quality matches and they burn out faster.
The beauty of having arcade rules and waiting in line is that, it puts more pressure on the players to perform well on each match. And if they lose and get back in line they get to rest. In this system you can put more energy on each of your matches while not getting burnt out because of the waiting period.
This is how it was for me in the 3S days when I went to Camelot every Friday after Southern Hills closed down. There was always a crowd of people waiting around the 3S machine. When it was my turn to play, I put everything into the match. If I lost it was ok because I got to rest because the match was so intense. When I got back up I could play hard again and then I would win and get on a role haha.
But the point is the whole idea of playing and waiting was cool because it gave you a good pacing. You would be at the arcade the whole night without feeling burnt out.
Another major reason of one match only (Arcade Rules) with few set ups is that people get to play more players. It’s better to win with 10 people in the rotation then 2 people in the rotation. I don’t like it when people hide behind their own set up and get in their own comfort zone. When I had 4 SSF4 set ups that happened a lot. And in my mind I always felt that there was something wrong here lol. But hey it’s ok because now I have an opportunity to really enforce it with MVC3.