few good ones on my mind:
the evo 2009 commentators were pretty good… just please not the ones that commentated during the first day of NCR last week.
Where the hell is Chris Hu in the poll???
Seth Killian and James Chen. They’re well spoken and they have pretty extensive technical/matchup knowledge. Another bonus is that they’re the only two commentators I can think of who don’t pick fights with people in stream chat, which is irritating and unprofessional. If this scene is ever going to leave the basement, behavior like that and repetitive usage of the same tired catchphrases (real talk! on blast!) should be left behind.
Taylor Henry, definitely.
My favorite Rockefeller quote:
“Amir jumps over… Pyro hits forward fierce… connects… Yun’s forward fierce hit right there because it hits both ways… like a bisexual prostitute…”
Rock would be godlike, but in his absence I vote for Seth Killian and Seb. I would also give a blanket anti-vote to anyone from the East Coast scene. I don’t need to hear about people being on blast every single round.
Evo commentary needs 3 things:
As much as I loved Rock’s commentary because it was raunchy, colorful, and totally hilarious, I think the scene has grown into a position where the years biggest event should strive to be as professional as possible.
SkiSonic for HYPE, and Seth Killian for some serious talk, they would play off each other well, and I think it’d be a perfect pair.
Why not more votes for Dog Face? Dude is fucking hilarious.
Play-by-play = Seth Killian
Color = Dog Face
I think the pair of S-Kill/Yipes would be VERY hard to beat. IMO the best play-by-play and color commentators in the scene
we need boop bop wit da shnoop snop commentary
rEal ToK!
Skillian for top tier commentator.
Seb, Killian, with Hu rotated here and there. :>
No Magus option? Fail!
I want to hear Magus and S-kill both commentate. It would be god like!
[media=youtube]F8B9z3TxJpo[/media]
These Guys
Ah thx for the few mentions your too kind, no seriously you are 
To me it’s an obvious choice, you have Seth, Ski, Chen, Art, Yipes, Hu and drunken Negro Ninja and you golden crisps!
Wow, so few votes for Rockefeller. You guys just don’t know.
He’s better than everyone else in the list, combined!
Actually, by votes, that would be Skillian. lmao
Rockefeller is GOD LIKE! watch some of the old 3s vids where he commentates , man is a genious.These people literally JDK
I want to see all those plus Yipes and Chris Hu commentate TOGETHER.
Have them all tag team. Looking at Keits, Ski, and S-kill, they brought 110% for us viewers at home, and they need a well deserved rest from time to time. You could tell they were worn down in that weekend, but it didn’t show in their commentating at all though.
Gotta give a shout out to MAGUS also. He brings KNOWLEDGE + LOLZ. Too awesome imo. Especially for the lolz.
Ski, Chen, s-kill. Honorable mention to Magus.
As long as Hu isn’t talking on the stream, it’d be fine.
Honestly, any combination of S-kill, Ski, Chen, and Hu would be fantastic.