Which game is more random, Marvel or Smash?

lol this thread is going to turn into a shitstorm

Smash is more random.

did you ever play marvel?:looney:

Yeah, pretty sad that Smash is at Evo in the first place. However you bring up some moot points–every gamer noob plays that game. Same with Halo and Call of Duty. Of course they would out number every other game. They are so far removed from the fighter community that is amazing the game shares the stage with GG, VF, mvc2, and ST.

Pressing a lot of buttons does in no way mean it is comparable to real fighting games.

never listen to someone who has digimon in their handle…

lets make things clear.

Marvel is broken…not random

Smash is random

Why don’t you think Smash deserves a spot at Evo?

You can tell he’s never really played the game…

(here comes the “I played that weak ass shit!” post.)

Marvel is one of my favorite games of all time, and I like Smash ok, but to say it isn’t a real fighting game and doesn’t deserve to be in Evo is just straight ignorance or bias (or both.) Someone brought up a good point, Smash is more technical than people want to give it credit for. L-canceling is hard to do consistently and it has more strategy in it than a lot of fighters. When people say it’s not a rel fighting game, it’s EXACTLY like when some average Joe-blow gamer looks at SF and says it’s not deep or technical. Is it more technical than Marvel, hell no, but it’s a good game and deserves to be in Evo.

cause its wack?

because that spot should goto a real game like VF5. Also wiz should be in the poor house and eating canned beans every night.

See, even you admit that shit is weak sauce. Also, I am no longer 13 years old so I have no interest in the game.

Smash is more random just due to the way certain characters have abilities.

For instance, Peach’s Forward Smash is actually 3 different ones, but it’s random whether you’re getting the Golf Club, Frying Pan, or Tennis Racket for it. Each of them has their own range. Her Turnips are also random as depending on the more “sickly” look of them, the more damage they deal, but it’s random depending on which one comes out. And even sometimes she’ll also pull out items.

Game & Watch is also random with his forward special attack. You could get a “1”, which does crap for damage, or get a “9” and KO someone instantly.

And as for the whole Smash isn’t technical and not worthy of being a tournament game is complete BS. The game is more technical than most other 2D or 3D fighters I’ve ever played when you get to the tournament level. Wavedashing in Melee has to be one of the hardest things to do (you have to spend a lot of time to do it consistently and then be able to utilize it in competition) and in tournament level play it is considered BASIC MOVEMENT in order to just compete. Combine that with the whole ShFFLing thing and you have to have ridiculous hand dexterity to play.

Smash is more whack than this thread.

It’s at EVO yeah, but hey, shit happens.

Justin Wong getting into marvel finals every year sure is random to me.

And items in smash can be turned off, and will be, for serious tournament play.

this thread is and will go nowhere.

:rofl:
yea i would never put smash over cvs2, gg, or vf5 in a heartbeat…hell, id rather see doa than smash…seriously

Wow, so you play play a game with Comic Book characters? You must be REALLY grown up.

^comicbook characters>>>>>>>>>yoshi and those other gay characters…

Yeah it really irks me how this is going to turn into another SRK war that everyone can just never get enough of. My game vs. your game WREUEUEARHAHHAH!!! WHO IS DA VICTOR!!! I say whichever game is better at Russian Roulette is less random.

It seems you got a problem with Comic Book characters.
Its Marvel, not Robin Hood…

So u love Pokemon than Marvel, right?
Storm Kills that Pikachu…

That’s what I was thinking.

You have got to be shitting me. Smash finals are MAD hype, whens the last time anyone got that excited over DoA/Tekken/VF? I think the only time the majority of Evo participants enjoyed watching VF was when we had that Japanese announcer come like 4 years ago.