Oh right. Earlier on Carbunkle Flux asked me if Reisen’s potions were worth using over Control Rods. I went and tested it with various upgrades. So here we have potions vs control rods and potions vs substitute doll.
The opponent is Reimu and the attack I’m using is Reisen’s default 236 rocket attack.
A rocket by itself (unupgraded) does 1532 damage
Potion 1: 1675 damage
Potion 2: 1831 damage
Potion 3: 1905 damage
and of course we aren’t using a 4th potion because that blows her up and does a crappy attack in the process, eradicating all her buffs. Never use a 4th potion.
Control Rod 1: 1682
Control Rod 2: 1831
Control Rod 3: 1979
Control Rod 4: 2127
So in terms of damage, control rods win. You can add an extra control rod in there to get an extra level of damage, and they are slightly more powerful buffers to begin with. However, they detract from your defense while potions give you more defense. Let’s see how that squares up.
The next test was done with Reimu using her charged 5C on Reisen at point blank range.
normally this attack did 1556 damage to Reisen.
Potion 1: 1403
Potion 2: 1325
Potion 3: 1249
Control Rod 1: 1669
Control Rod 2: 1785
Control Rod 3: 1898
Control Rod 4: 2012
So yeah, Reisen takes a lot of damage if you use control rods. But let’s check the control rod + shield combo.
Control + shield 1: 1588
Control + shield 2: 1610
Control + shield 3: 1617
Control + shield 4: 1418
So you see here that max control rod + max shield gives you more defense than you originally had, plus a huge boost in attack. Still, three potions alone gives you better defense and almost as much of an attack boost.
Now let’s do potions + shields.
Potion + shield 1: 1334
Potion + shield 2: 1195
Potion + shield 3: 1063
Potion + shield 4 (no extra potion): 878
Lol wow.
And now Shield + Control rod + potion. AKA God Bunny.
God Bunny 1: takes 1430 damage, does 1928
God Bunny 2: takes 1371 damage, does 2187
God Bunny 3: takes 1298 daamage, does 2460
God Bunny 4 (no extra potion): takes 1138 damage, does 2644
And finlly, God Bunny with rocket boosts:
Control Rod 1 + Potion 1 + Rocket 0: 1928
Control Rod 1 + Potion 1 + Rocket 1: 2117
Control Rod 2 + Potion 2 + Rocket 2: 2611
Control Rod 3 + Potion 3 + Rocket 3: 3171
Control Rod 4 + Potion 3 + Rocket 4: 3654
So yeah. All in All, I think the potions are a better bet even though they consume more cards. In order to get a slightly better effect from the system cards, you need to declair 8 times and even then you don’t get as much defense and just a bit more attack. With potions you only need to declair 3 times, even though the potions leave you a bit more vulnerable each time.
Of course, if you want to be a hog and use all of them in the same deck, then good luck because the rewards of combining potions with control rods or shields is pretty good.