Trust me, it was an honest mistake.
I swear, if the Mafia win this game just because I made that post… I don’t fucking know.
- For your first point I think it’d be easier if you had the right partner. You could bounce ideas, phrases and posts off of them before posting in the thread. You wouldn’t have to deal with 5 other mafia members and personalities, just one other person. I have you pegged as having Coco or Mobius for partners if you’re mafia. Mobius because he followed suit in controlling the signal to noise ratio with you, along with generally being very responsive to your posts. Coco because he literally hasn’t posted shit in the thread. It’s entirely possible for him to be on an alt account or on fb or something talking with you about whatever you guys had cooking.
As for posting a lot you didn’t at first. In fact it wasn’t until more people started dying that you creeped up in the rankings (please don’t make me count any more post. Unlike pimp willy I don’t have a fancy smancy program that can do the counting for me). Your voting doesn’t really indicate the amount of research you did either. BullDancer you relied on past game logic. Saitsu was due to you lacking in reads and Manx… Well he was playing really suspiciously.
If Syn had survived that night my initial frontrunners were you and coco for my lynch vote for the next day. But after he died I couldn’t risk pointing the finger at one of the only people contributing. *
Right. As I’ve said before, research matters more in the later stages of the game, where you have more trends to go on. When placing those votes, I had to go on the best information I had at that time. Between it being early in the game and the abundance of wallflowers, I readily admit to having made uninformed decisions. But that is sort of what the game is all about.
As for your theories, I can’t disprove them, naturally.
Keep pressing me if you want… Maybe we can get more people to slip like GR just did. (Not that that slip was 100% damning, and don’t think I didn’t notice that Möbius slipped too.)
It’s funny, this screw up. Even if I was Mafia, it’d make me suck.
Civ: Get lynched, GAME OVER
Mafia: Get lynched, lose a perfect opportunity to win
Truly worthy of a Non-Star Game.
I’m gonna go to sleep. I know I’m an idiot, but don’t make the wrong choice, guys.
Did I though?~
I merely presented a “what if” if Co-Jones is a civ.
However, feel free to consider that as a slip if it would help your case.
Fair enough, but your post did not include that “what if”, so I have to take it on face value.
@mobius, if you had to vote right now, whom would you vote for?
*If I had to vote right now, I’m not sure who I would vote for to be honest. The only solace I have is the 50/50 chance of nailing a mafia. *
I know, hence, there’s nothing wrong with you suspecting me.
Remember that time when Synonym misinterpreted Manx’s role, the one with the “spy” and I tried to interpret it with my version, I did that again albeit flakier this time around. I assumed that Godots meant that as a what-if if Co-Jones was a civ.
My suspect, it’s still Co-Jones,
Here’s the reason why I had my sights locked on him since Day 2,
Was something I expressed on page 2 in a banter with Synonym.
After BullDancer was revealed as the UC,
This was on page 6.
This coupled with other reasons I’ve already stated and the points others presented in this thread.
I know this is insufficient since Co-Jones gave us few things to work with.
Ok. I think what we really need is to put CJ on the stand. I’m going to bed. I’ll answer any questions you may have in the morning. Hopefully CJ will show up earlier rather than later.
*What are everyone here thoughts on Co-Jones not signing in for 2 days? *
If he’s Mafia, he’s taking a big risk. If he’s civ, he’s a jerk. A big one.
Since you’re the only one responding, Godot what do you think of the remaining players?
It could be mind games to set him aside for another day or it could be not.
Puzzling, that’s for sure.
Co-Jones: Too quiet, I think he’s Mafia (Well, I hope he’s Mafia. Like I said, if he doesn’t show up and he’s civ…). Plus I’ve been on him the whole game, so I won’t go into more explanation right now. Top 1 suspect.
Mobius: He’s been speculating the whole game, but not really contributing. He’s been onto Co-Jones as well, so if Co-Jones is Mafia, I think it may be possible that the both of them are Mafia and are against each other to make them seem civ. Just take pietastic’s theory about me and Co-Jones being Mafia together and replace my name with Mobius’.
DarkGeneral: Always contributing, always pushing the discussion forward. I’m a bit suspicious on how he suddenly made Pietastic VS DarkGeneral a thing in this last Day Phase (We need all 3 votes on a Mafia to win. If votes are spread out, we lose), but he’s been helpful enough that I’m willing to overlook it.
Pietastic: I’ve trusted him the whole game because he was good at contributing and made new observations about players. I’m not sure if he’s been more or less helpful than DarkGeneral. I’ve trusted him way too much in this game. If he turns up Mafia I’m going to feel like an idiot for trusting him so much.
**By the way Co-Jones, I am keeping my lynch vote on you until you show up. If you’re civ, I can’t believe you’re MIA on the most important Day Phase. **
I may keep my vote on you anyways, but either way you need to get over here.
By waiting for CJ this long into the day phase, we are making ourselves extremely vulnerable to late-game mafia vote swinging.
Lynch: The Co-Jones.
Echo GR: CJ, if you are actually civ, you done goofed your teammates.
DO NOT LYNCH ME IF WE WANNA WIN.
I’ve had a disgusting case of food poisoning, couple with some nasty diarrhea the last 3 days, but I was at the hospital for the severity of the food poisoning.
*This wording bothers me. *
Wow, so you popped up immediately after I vote for you? Did your mafia buddy message you and tell you to check in?
Who do you suspect, why, and why is that suspect better than you?
At this point, “just trust me” is not a good answer.
He’s back!
I keeping my lynch vote on you until you argue against all my other points.