SRK MAFIA XVII - ATTACK ON TITAN:End of Day 8 - The Grim Reminder (Civilians lose!)

[Vynce]

Let’s say you’re both civs.

What do you guys make of LordWilliam?

[Pimp_Willy]

Dormant that was recruited night 2, or Oz’s lover

[Vynce]

@RF, I didn’t take his Bious’ post at face value. When you’re excited about something that puts you in a better position but you don’t want to appear to be, be the first to say something about it…

By that logic the plan would be that Bious & Pimp were playing “good civ bad civ” by having one point out the obvious “he’s trying to help us” factor and the other pointing out the “why” factor.

You can have your popcorn. As for me, toast sounds pretty good right about now.

By the way @Vynce you’re confirmed civ, unless Hecatom comes back with an affirmative on the following question.

@Hecatom if the Mafia attempt to recruit someone who’s already Mafia will the writeup say that a recruit failed?

That’d be a shrewd play. I’d have thought of it. I don’t know that I’d trade a potential recruit to confirm myself as a civ, though. If you take that writeup as confirmation.

Recruit’s not goin anywhere.

But I digress.

Pimp I don’t have enough time to discuss with you for a few hours but I’ll have access later.

AC, gotcha.

I meant spending the phase on the ruse. I wouldn’t do it. If I was fake-confirming a Chief or Synonym, then perhaps. I wouldn’t agree to it, I should say. This is digression, but hey.

[Vynce]

We can change votes leading up to the deadline, right? I haven’t submitted one yet, in any case.

[jasonC]

You can’t change votes if you’ve submitted to Hecatom already. And I think LordWilliam is civ.

[The_Chief]

My Current Gut Reads (Which mean shit I know)

Mafia:
Chief
DukeC
SAD

Lover:
JasonC

Dormants:
LordWilliam
Cyntalan
BK

Hunch right?

You’ve been 100% wrong but you’re 100% sure I’m mafia. lololol

[AlphaCommando]

Some of the posts that D’nyc3 have made are pretty susp and I agree that he’s a good candidate to lynch from the wallflower heap. However I think that he can wait until tomorrow to see if he’ll come around to avoid getting DQ’d today.

If majority of thread feels this way, will ease up on Denise until tomorrow. Add to theory:
-D’Nyc3 is untaggable. All responses to people questioning have been from Mafia PM alerting D’Nyc3 to questions.
If not DQ’d today, most likely personal lynch target Day 5.

Focus shift to other D Posters: Icege and RECESSIONTIME.

Voting Patterns of Icege
Day 1: LordWilliam1234
Day 2: Did Not Vote
Day 3: No Lynch

Voting Patterns of RECESSIONTIME
Day 1: Did Not Vote
Day 2: Augustus
Day 3: The Chief

Icege Analysis:
-Claims to be catching up from page 8 onwards with “today and tonight” free. 12 hours later, still catching up from page 8.
-Behaviour has been seen previously (even as GM), usually details about time problems given (minor details given this game).
-NoodleHead Blackbook Notes: Icege high observational skill and analytical ability.

RECESSIONTIME Analysis:
-Low post count typical behaviour.
-Has been DQ’d due to minimal participation.
-No explanations to lynch targets given.

Both deemed risks, Icege higher possibility of Mafia behaviour.

Lynch: Icege

Not locked in.

Willing to switch back to D’Nyc3 if thread views as viable lynch target.

[AlphaCommando]

Pimp Willy Micro-Analysis:
-Activity and behaviour inconsistent with usual PW Mafia tendencies. Reason included in ‘Most Likely Civilian’ list.
-Several tells usually displayed while Mafia not displayed.
-Night killed players do not match predicted PW targets.

LordWilliam1234 Micro-Analysis:

Spoiler

Also, for the record, I didn’t directly want Augustus lynched, just looked into. My list isn’t for lynching, just for who we should perhaps focus on. Twice now these bandwagons on one player just have not worked.

Anyways, out of the player list, imo:

Blindknagg: Civ?
Augustus: Civ
Pimp Willy: Civ
DarkGeneral: ???
Skizzz: Civ
D’Nyc3: ???
jasonC: Civ
AlphaCommando: Civ
DukeC: Civ
Cyntalan: ???
RECESSIONTIME: ???
Sumazndude: ???
The Co-Jones: Civ (was this confirmed or was it only that he’s not mafia?)
Icege: ???
Bious: ???
The Chief: Civ

The ones marked ??? are the ones I think that should be focused on this go 'round. Blindknagg’s marking is since I’m not really sure one way or the other. D’Nyc3 might just not be around? I haven’t seen much of him and he did miss his vote this time, though he voted for Day 2. Similar case for @Skizzz.

I’m not gonna be around most of the day though so this’ll be my last contribution for a while. I might pop in in about 3 hours (around lunch-time here) but outside of that, I’ll be missing in action.

I’ll leave the rest to all of you.

-List matches up with personal list. Top of ‘Most Likely Civilian’ list (excluding The Co-Jones).
-Contributions deemed helpful, agreeable and insightful.
-Little to no actions to suggest Mafia behaviour.

Personal opinion: Both high probability of Civilian status.

[jasonC]

Ok Alpha. I’m with ya.

Lynch Icege

[DukeC]

Welp. Since we know Pimp Willy is 100% wrong 100% of the time that confirms that I’m civ.

Thanks for the compliment Pimp.

[RadicalFuzz]

Icege and DG in particular have both said “I’ll have free time to play by X date” and haven’t begun posting more if they are.

Pop quiz: You’re Mafia, and one of your members has been deathly inactive, barely avoiding getting DQd. What would you have them do, assuming they’re back.

@ Chidf & @Vynce are you still committed to the Wymp Pylly Bandwaygn?

[The_Chief]

With unwavering hate.

My prediction that DukeC, Blindknagg and JasonC would vote elsewhere means I need to keep following my read on Pimp until given reason to deviate.

[Pimp_Willy]

With unwavering hate.

My prediction that DukeC, Blindknagg and JasonC would vote elsewhere means I need to keep following my read on Pimp until given reason to deviate.

Then you can join me in the terrible reads club! Depending on your motivation : )

[RadicalFuzz]

With unwavering hate.

My prediction that DukeC, Blindknagg and JasonC would vote elsewhere means I need to keep following my read on Pimp until given reason to deviate.

Then you can join me in the terrible reads club! Depending on your motivation : )

“Terrible Reads Club! Don’t make one and walk away!”

We have a winner.

[Skizzz]

@AlphaCommando‌ I would agree that there is most likely at least 1 mafia among the really low posters (Ice, RT, D’nyc3). Imo it’s icege, like for example just look at this post from day 1 and tell me it’s not a mafia claim coming from an experienced player.

I’m going to lynch BlindWilliam1234 because he’s done even less than me despite being one of the first to check in.

Also, @RadicalFuzz‌ I had the same thought, but it says that DG has not been active for 5 days, so I’m inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt

[Skizzz]

Also, @RadicalFuzz‌ I had the same thought, but it says that DG has not been active for 5 days, so I’m inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt

*benefit of the doubt for now

[Vynce]

Icege and DG in particular have both said “I’ll have free time to play by X date” and haven’t begun posting more if they are.

Pop quiz: You’re Mafia, and one of your members has been deathly inactive, barely avoiding getting DQd. What would you have them do, assuming they’re back.

@ Chidf & @Vynce are you still committed to the Wymp Pylly Bandwaygn?

I’m not locked in yet

[Cyntalan]

@ Chidf & @Vynce are you still committed to the Wymp Pylly Bandwaygn?

Fuzz, go home, you’re drunk.

[Vynce]

Wait, there’s a NoodleHead black book? Am I in it? Does he think I’m cool?

[The_Chief]

Icege and DG in particular have both said “I’ll have free time to play by X date” and haven’t begun posting more if they are.

Pop quiz: You’re Mafia, and one of your members has been deathly inactive, barely avoiding getting DQd. What would you have them do, assuming they’re back.

@ Chidf & @Vynce are you still committed to the Wymp Pylly Bandwaygn?

I’m not locked in yet

What is this treachery!