Alright, I’ll list out what I think makes you dirty:
Night 1 Kill:[details=Spoiler]You can’t avoid this. The Mafia killed one of the most important roles in the game Night 1, which means the Mafia either got lucky with rolehunting/random killing, killed TGG because he was considered almost definitely civilian by one or two players, or were killing him on a read. Your reads are ridiculous, at least as Mafia when you have more information to go off of, so naturally you’ll be a suspect for this one regardless of anything you do in the thread[/details]
Behavior:[details=Spoiler]Day 1 you proposed a plan about Expeditions. You talked about it for a bit and let it drop before it sparked much discussion. This was also before the limitation on the groups having to be the same size was made public.
Day 1 you forgot to vote and/or didn’t have time to. The next day you (and Pimp) get on Forge’s case about not getting every single vote or mention of vote in the thread and lightly push suspicion onto her for it.
Day 3 you seem exasperated at the events in thread, presumably because activity levels are low and there’s very little constructive communication. Yet when the spotlight for the lynch goes onto you, when multiple people are analyzing what you say more closely than usual, you lash out at lack of evidence against you and hole up, refusing to help (your words) until we either make a case against you or you die.
To me that behavior coming from you as a civilian doesn’t make much sense[/details]
Final Fantasy XIV:[details=Spoiler]You’re a freaking ER doctor, how do you have time for an MMO? I’m calling bullshit on this one.
No, this is not a serious point.
Side note: Is it a fun game that’ll last a long while or just good for a short run? I’ve seen a lot of friends playing it over the past few months and I’m curious.[/details]
You haven’t been Mafia in a long time have you Pimp?
Night kill is still pretty ambiguous. If I was mafia, I would have killed TGG regardless of any role read on him. He was new enough that his death didn’t implicate anyone, he was active enough that the mafia probably didn’t like that, and he was trying hard to contribute good quality stuff instead of fluff.
Day 1 plan was based on my understanding of the rules at the time. I still think it was a good idea but everyone called me mafia because I proposed a plan. that’s why I backed off.
Day 1 I was busy. I have a job, and that supersedes any game commitments.
I am genuinely pissed off at how lazy civilians are on this site. To be honest, I’ve considered retiring from playing here a few times over the last couple of games. Of everyone playing, only about 20% have been doing any serious work.
Look at this shit:
LordWilliam1234 Posts: 30 (New player and has more posts than all of these guys)
Bious Posts: 26 (Seriously? This is the guy you’re believing over me?)
Sumazndude Posts: 24 (Holy fuck, SAD isn’t last?)
Combo_Knight Posts: 23 (Well you’re off the radar)
DarkGeneral Posts: 16 (Soon to be DeadGeneral)
The Co-Jones Posts: 12
Exodus. Posts: 11
D’Nyc3 Posts: 7 (Who the fuck is this guy?)
GodotsRevenge Posts: 6 (Definitely deserves to live longer than me)
Icege Posts: 5 (He’s chimed in with an excuse)
RECESSIONTIME Posts: 4 (Much more helpful than me too)
Clearly all of these guys are much more useful to the civilian cause than I am.
I have from page 8 - 20 to catch up on. Cliff notes that I saw were no bueno -_-
I sent in a no lynch vote because there isn’t really a good vote for me to make. I’m not all too caught up on what is going on let alone getting any type of gut reactions.
I’m not going to sit here and argue this with you for the next half hour.
You have taken actions which make me think you’re Mafia. The only actions Icege has taken are “I’m catching up guys, really” posts every day or so. While those don’t make him look clean necessarily it’s unlikely that Mafia members would let a teammate post so many of those statements.
And more pragmatically it’s too late to go back at this point. Deadline’s in half an hour, votes are locked in this format, and not enough people are online.
Assuming that you’re civ I can understand why you’re upset you’re getting mislynched while so many people aren’t giving a fuck about the game. If what Alpha said about you expecting the other players to be of equal or similar skill to you then you’re not going to find it in this game, and not on this site the majority of the time. Most of us aren’t as good at Mafia as you are, we’re wrong just as often if not more often than we’re right, and we don’t learn enough from our mistakes. The best we can do is try, and that’s what we’re doing right now, trying to lynch Mafia because we fucked up big time already and the Mafia is doing well.