So that means we know that Alpha is civilian until tomorrow. Splendid. Maybe you’ll actually do something with that status unlike someone~ else
Going by that logic the people that have been more silent than I should be your suspects. But I can’t really answer your question since I don’t have a solid reason besides “I’m civ.”
I’ll share my thoughts when I’m good and ready.
The people that have been more silent than you haven’t popped out of nowhere and said that we should ONLY be suspecting person X or person Y.
Because we should. I’m highly positive one of them is Mafia.
Okay I’ll stop bugging you about it.
While I don’t agree we should be the only options, I have no qualms with Syn other than. I’ve been wrong all game and am afraid to be wrong again
Who are you and what have you done with Pimp Willy?
Look I told oz to shut the fuck up about his fake role claim and probably caused him to not release the name, I done fucked up lol
Guess that means pink Willy is clean. No way a civilian is advocating that we avoid discussing information. That’s literally the most retarded suggestion you’ve ever made. “Hey guys, let’s just twiddle our thumbs for the rest of the phase. Oh, that guy wasn’t Mafia? Shit, guess we don’t have anything to go on.”
It’s almost worth dying and ruining my streak just to rub it in at how badly you’ve fucked up.
I’d rather lynch a Mafia though.
And what are your suspicions of Pimp Willy and Synonym?
I’m currently re-reading the thread to see what I can gather, and building a data sheet.
yay LW - finally getting into it. Hope you enjoy and by the end of all this you’ll see why people keep playing this even though we all pretty much suck at it.
May I suggest we use my CYNTALAN TEST to role claim civs? Don’t write the answer directly in the thread, just use the letters in doublespeak in the thread.
@Synonym
What do you think of Chief, Bious, Sumazndude, and Pimp Willy so far?
Any peculiar thoughts about Icege or Cyntalan? Or how about the other two people getting heat in BK and CK?
Your response to being suspected is giving me deja vu. I’d appreciate it if you could ease my concerns by answering my questions.
Before I change my vote to Syn, I am waiting for him to say “lol I’m Mafia”
Chief is too quiet and not explaining his reads. That in itself isn’t too unusual for him but he’s just quieter than usual. Bious is rapidly becoming my number 1 suspect. He’s been repeatedly trying to get me lynched on no evidence then disappearing.
Pink is always suspicious. It’s just how he pays these games. As much as I want to lynch him, it’ll probably just end with him being ruleless.
SAD is either dormant or Mafia I’m guessing. Possibly Mafia recruit.
Icege is a good player so I can’t understand why he’s this absent.
Cynt I’m not sure about. He’s not on my immediately must die list.
Bk I wasn’t sure about on d1, but I’m more willing to lynch him now. Ck has been my suspect all game so I’d be willing to lynch him.
As for the déjà vu, well that’s why I’m always a suspect. I try not to play differently as Mafia. Although I do have a few Mafia tells.
Herein lies the problem. Someone has to see the edit for it to have any meaning. To ensure someone sees it the person could possibly say “I’ll do it at X time” but then that information is also available to the Mafia. I guess what I’m asking is how exactly would it work? I couldn’t figure out a way for it to be reliable.
Info dump on PW:
[details=Spoiler]In regards to Pimp Willy, he said he was locking in on Synonym back on Day 1, then said his Mafia radar was beeping for Synonym, ForgeDigger and OZ (the latter two who were killed and lynched respectively, but it was long after these initial suspicions), then locked his vote in on Synonym when it came to the Day 1 voting, and was the only one who ended up voting for Synonym (Synonym missed the voting entirely for that day). Claimed that he puts OZ on his list because OZ is “the best at hiding being Mafia.” As well as adding this:
Afterwards he also posted this when Skizzz asked him if he could do post counts this game:
Unnecessary mentions of mafia killing him or being voted off, completely unrelated to the question at hand. Trying too hard to act innocent?
Later claims that he still thinks Synonym but “will gain no traction.”
Day 1 voting results, Pimp Willy votes for Synonym.
Pimp Willy mentions that the tie vote on Day 1 may have been a forced tie, which could show a potential Mafia member. Also later shows that perhaps either Exodus. or DarkGeneral possibly forced the tie.
Continuing from that Pimp Willy claims to be switching his vote from Synonym to DarkGeneral, presumably due to the above. Claims he’ll lock it (PM it) as soon as the Day 2 phase starts.
Night phase ends, TGG is killed. PW posts:
Also says once again that he puts his vote on DG.
When RadicalFuzz asks him about his plan in regards to an expedition, PW isn’t in favor of it (refers to it as an excursion though), claims he’ll think on it overnight.
PW later says this:
So didn’t follow through with his DG vote. Also note that he has Forge “as a noose victim,” who coincidentally dies the next Night Phase.
Says that TGG may have been an attempt to frame someone and not a role hunt (thinks that Syn may be the one that’s being framed). Also says that he’s not going after DG because he was basically told to back off and won’t push it until he gets some evidence.
Says that AlphaCommando being alive after Day 1 is suspicious enough regardless of his behavior.
When Synonym responds to accusations about him missing his vote, and says that he won’t be lynched so we can trust PW, PW responds with:
Also later tells RadicalFuzz to say “what his gut says.” Claims that he’s been pretty up front with his gut.
When RadicalFuzz says that PW doesn’t want to know what his gut says, PW says:
Note that Synonym is back on that list (though it could be because of the earlier exchange between them), Forge is still there and despite the fact he was gonna back off DG, he’s still on that list.
Then starts going after OZ, closing in on the deadline for the voting. Refutes what OZ is saying to defend himself. Then says this when OZ claims to be one of the lover pairs:
Then he claims to lock in on oz shortly afterwards.
After the proceeding night phase, when ForgeDigger is killed, PW claims that he would have lynched ForgeDigger anyway. Soon afterwards he asks (in response to one of RadicalFuzz’s posts about Syn and Alpha being higher on his list) if they can please lynch syn finally.
Eventually claims to be doubting himself and his reads, and of course adds me to his suspect list.[/details]
I see some things that could be considered suspicious but nothing that’s overall damning. I’m not sure if PW is the one we should focus on at the moment, but that’ll be for you all to decide.
I took the liberty of directly quoting some of what PW said so you can jump to that part of the thread and look further into his reactions and the posts of others in relation to what he said.
Not really. It was never a case of me seeing why other people keep playing this, it was a case of myself not wanting to/being unable to really play this game. I can gather info but that doesn’t mean I can process it or make reads. Or defend my accusations, for that matter.
We just use my current edit that I did for Cynt. The answer was not posted yet. So let’s say the answer is “hikes” so for example, a claim would be something like:
“Why hasn’t AC posted in a while? Don’t tell me he got it from a drop bear on one of those aussie hikes” or
“Cyntalan, or should I say, Dormant? Hi! keskeskeskes”
Or course it would only be effective for the first few claims before somebody cracks the code. But anything helps right?