I’m not defending OZ.
@kaz I liked him better as Mable 
So like any provacative post we must decide does suggesting this idea lead pie to look more innocent or more guilty? Also gambler’s fallacy at play as this would be his third game as mafia if he is. I can’t tell whether I should put pie at the top or bottom of my potential suspect list so yeah I’m not being very helpful yet I know.
@bious You were dead set on AC then instantly switched to Aidebit once I said he was being more active than usual, why the sudden change?
Being the first to suggest the lynching wall flowers strategy…welll considering how in the dark the civs are this game it certainly isn’t the worst idea.
saves draft How confident are you in these reads and would you mind explaining the reasoning behind this list?
There is definitely something fishy going on between bious, AC, and RF, I think at least 1 of them is mafia, but I’m not so confident that I’d stake my life on it.
@sumazndude why go in on @aidebit after he backed off of you?
This post is really out of left field, why vote for GR at this point? Did you think this post would convince us to vote GR?
@Duke
His post came of more as a “here’s Chief’s targets and outside of them I also suspect Duke” to me.
Your point A may be seen as role hunting but your new so I’ll let that one slide.
And @orochizoolander you owe me one coin in the next arena game.
I initially read this as you responding to someone else’s red herring.
If that were the case why didn’t he at least name or suggest one of them like his post said? Why only myself?
Did he expect everyone to remember who was on Chief’s list at the very beginning of the game? The only one whose name has consistently come up is Apha’s. In any case his post seemed to indicate I was also on Chief’s list, with the way he left off names. Even I went “Huh” and went back to check Chief’s list.
If it matters I responded to Fuzz. Just wanted my opinion out there.
Too many others are
I find this hella suspect.
I dunno why he posted after night phase, but that isn’t my reasoning. Still waiting on an explanation as to why he was Captain Citizen on day one, and after I called him on it, SILENCE.
Ah ok I see what you mean now. Still don’t think he tried to paint you as one of Chief’s targets since I assume most of us would go back to read that list just to make sure.
On one hand, he’s forever earned my perpetual suspicion ever since the FGC Vs. Illuminati game.
On the other, the last game kinda solidified my sense that he’s the lost stooge.
I’m not defending him. It’s more along the lines of a, “Meh, sky’s blue.”
Oh yeah, there it is. Not what I thought, in context.
Fair enough. Though why no discussion of his day one activities, and the sheer rush of people defending him.
Keep this in mind for when we inevitably find he is mafia. Will give us a good list of other potential mafia
I was thinking the same thing, like he’s mafia or he has an important civ role.
I thought the same, but if he was a good civ role he wouldn’t be so…shady, for a lack of better terms
@Orochizoolander, @Bloodymess, The only reason I went in on Aidebit was because of his vote choice and his reason to vote for Fuzz. Frankly, I don’t think I ever read up on his reason for voting for Fuzz. It seemed unreasonable to see Aidebit so forward on voting for someone on Day 1. It’s almost like he came out a little too strong and fast for me. It just seemed like he was out of character EVEN THOUGH he said he was going to try and catch up on post count with me… sorry @Aidebit 
OZ like so many of us are just naturally shady lol.
And OZ just bounces off the wall with insanity at points.
Hopefully this comes out right, but here’s Exodus.’ last gasp:
B|
I wasn’t expecting this at all, baby, damn. Synonym and DarkGeneral probably have the best insights as to why I was knocked off. Surviving to late game, because I don’t push lynches unless I really think I have something, but if that was mafia’s intentions they could’ve waited another night or two so it was more than likely them trying to role hunt Vigi, I Shot the Sheriff, like DarkGeneral said. Usually when I look for roles I think of the person who keeps talking about the role, so essentially exactly what I was doing 
. So if there is a vigilante, which I still super doubt by the way, stay put! Also the crack at OZ in the lounge was GM sanctioned I made sure it was legal.
Down to brass tacks (thanks btw, Alpha, I had never known the correct expression)
Sorry to Aidebit. I was wrong about you. I Feel so Bad… I think one or two of the people that jumped on after me “trying to avoid a tie” might be bad. I mentioned that I thought a day one tie wouldn’t have been the worst thing to happen somewhere in the thread, because unlike a straight up unanimous No Lynch vote we could have looked at voting patterns anyways… That thought is going to be one of the leading bits of information as I go back over the thread to write this.
While I’m going through these remember I fucking hate day one so most of these are going to be bullshit and it will be glaringly obvious things later that I miss… but whatever… I’m blind fuck you.
DukeC
He was on Vynce’s ping list on page one. So he could have seen the thread go up and put off coming into the thread like a mafia or he could have genuinely missed it like I did for a couple of hours at least. He also had a triple post of filler-type OT stuff (good luck on mobile development though:tup:.) Nothing but speculation on him:
Is this him trying to say he isn’t cracking? Showing that he is willing to answer or something like that?
I still don’t understand this in the slightest. Sacrificing players is a tactic but usually its a way to gain trust and not really a numbers thing imo, and it usually makes the player stand out more rather than sink back to the darkness like DukeC’s hypothesis.
I think DukeC should die. Also he was on Chief’s O5 list so, why not?
Pietastic
Hey Now. Here is the guy that brought an important idea into the thread with the plan. I’m pretty sure the plan would work. What were Pie’s motivations for bringing it into the thread? I would be surprised if he thought everybody would go for it since it seems like a majority of people like to play the game to try to up their “reads” game and not for straight victory. He could have brought it up with the intention of looking helpful, i.e. the “Pimp Willy post count argument”, or he absolutely could have brought it in just to stir up conversation and get somebody to slip up in their response to the plan.
ForgeDigger
Didn’t like Pie’s plan for the same reason as myself.
Keeping this here just to make sure she comes back to comment on it. It coulda been that one thing that I won’t name so it can’t be stolen and there was never a plan.
BlindKnagg
Was my secondary target if Aidebit were to come up guilty.Due to some of their interactions with each other early on.
Missing Person
Ughh I’m getting to the end of my drive to do this….
Explain yo self. Especially the DukeC is clean claim.
OrochiZoolander
Lynch him because he’s a sillybilly that talks at night even though not talking was mentioned on like every fucking page so clearly he isn’t reading the thread. QED
Or it was another “EDIT” thing and should still be killed.
Dying is a blessing in disguise I guess… I don’t have a ton of extra time to Mess Around playing but I was kinda looking forward to playing anyways. Plus being blind is hell. Gotta get mah fix peace, boys. Don’t Let the Sun Catch You Cryin over me yall hear me na.
Huh. Some of that is solid reasoning, except I was going to ask questions anyway and I’ve already made peace with that making me suspicious in my first game.
Secondly, As for me responding to Vynce, that didn’t go as planned (that was a pretty bad bait I tried), so I took the L and stopped bothering him, especially since I don’t have a read on him at all
Thirdly, what list? If someone could actually show me this list where I’m on Chief’s suspects it’d be much appreciated, otherwise it just looks like I’m getting piled on for outright bogus reasons. This is the second time I’ve been accused on being on a list other than Vynce’s or Synonym’s. And it’s the same person, Chief. This is not helping soothe my earlier suspicion.
I wonder what Chief thinks of all this?
@DukeC - I think sometimes mafia will throw out a random name to see if it gets any bites, and if it does, they’ll start hunting for any and everything to help push the envelope. You’re one of the names being thrown. I’ve given you a free pass thus far.
The only thing ringing my bell regarding you is the shift in tone. I understand life reasons but it feels odd. I wont be around to push your lynch but I’d urge others to keep you on watch.
AlphaCommando feels I have nothing to go on regarding my reasoning for calling him out. I guess it depends on your perspective.
Ive grouped the players in the game and one of my groups has 2 key names on it right now: Pietastic and AlphaCommando. These two players are fine doing whatever they want regardless of the thread activity. I’ll reveal the full list shortly but for everyone playing, if you think the best way to get your suspects is to keep voting for them until they’re gone… you’re not helping.
I’m working on it. I haven’t had much free time to give the thread a good look. It’s not going to be amazingly helpful, but I’ll keep you posted all the same.
Hey, I’d be pretty disappointed in myself if I couldn’t decipher when you were mafia. Are you suggesting I can’t?