Good end of page 1 post here, that I almost just skipped by checking p1 for the role cards again.
Ok, quick reads because I still haven’t got everything sorted.
<Pimp Willy> is still a civilian. More than likely AlphaCommando knows his identity. Mafia seemed fairly confident that AC would get chosen hence his silencing. Assuming it wasn’t AC that received <Pimp Willy>'s name last night, feel free to name drop them at your own discretion.
Mafia know who <Icege> is. I’ve clarified with MP that medic can self-protect, but considering the order of actions goes: Enforce -> Medic (Enforced) ->Mafia kill we’re going to lose him tomorrow night.
@Chief, if you received any roles that aren’t: <Icege>, <Pimp Willy>, or mafia then just give us their alignment as well as roleless. We’ve bled enough roles before Day 2 as it is.
Here are my strongest blips at the moment:
-orochizoolander
-Bious
I’ve got a sneaky suspicion I know who <Pimp Willy> is but I’m not certain so I’ll leave that for now.
Yeah, I’m pretty sure Chief could have figured that out without you broadcasting it to the entire mafia, thanks for that though
Considering he posted AC’s plan to all and sundry I really don’t see the point in maintaining secrecy.
Mafia knows who the medic is, they obviously either got lucky using <RadicalFuzz> pre-game or they have some experienced players.
Maintaining transparency, you are higher than usual on my suspects list PW.
That’s fine, I wouldn’t have it any other way :tup:
I must say, you’re cropping up on mine though too. I can’t put my finger on why, but yeah, you’re pretty much sticking out to me.
I believe Chief doing what he did, was to cause a 50/50 mixup with AC, trying to look dirty in the process. By doing that, he was expecting the vigi to kill him, <PW> to hopefully present himself to him, and then grab us 2 names. Didn’t quite pan out like he expected, but I really hope that Chief got the <PW> name.
Of course, I’m pretty sure that AC was lying too. so there’s a chance He has the <PW> name, and the mafia knew that, and he was silenced and then tonight they’ll use the last gasp block to ensure that <PW> doesn’t actually get exposed. That’s why he was silenced. I really, really have a hard time believing that <Kaz>, after getting a new lease on life, outs himself right away to gain <PW>. Especially a solid player like AC. I think he was a Civ with a good plan, and chief knew that too. I’m just not sure which player got the name.
I know we also hate Role Claiming and I might get some hate, but is there any reason <Icege> should stay secret now? Mafia obviously knows who they are, shouldn’t we too?
Yeah I’m inclined to agree with PW about the silencing part.
I dunno how to take Cyntalan’s one post being a lynch on day one and then falling into complete silence until now. It might be nothing and well see what(if) he’ll post later but it does feel a little weird.
MP, you never answered before, is it ok that I post the post counts? Will that violate your “english only” rule or is it ok? I want to make sure before I do it
Post counts are totally fine. Foreign languages and encrypted posts are what I’m trying to stem.
Does it serve any purpose? Mafia could use it as a vehicle to avoid a lynch.
Unless the medic is dangerously close to being lynched all we’d get is a confirmed voice for 24 hours.
I’m playing a lot less carefully this game, if that helps narrow it down for you.
We are in disagreement here though. Personally, I believe AC is a civilian. I saw his plan and wanted to see it play out. Hopefully it did and we can find out after the next night phase. Players after all cannot be perpetually silenced, and mafia’s night kill will more than likely already be tied up.
I find this line to be interesting though:
Why is that interesting? Because you think I slipped up and somehow know there is a last gasp block? Glad to see you’re into the Jesus Toast, that’s worked out so well for everyone in the past : )
I see it serving one purpose, they have to claim before there is a lynch obviously, but in this case, the mafia literally knows who the Medic is, and the rest of us don’t. Is there ANY benefit to letting the Mafia know something we don’t? Is there any advantage to keeping him secret to all of us? If there is, fine, it just seems like Mafia knows something we don’t, and he is most likely dead tonight anyway if he outs himself or not. Or he will just keep getting enforced anyway, nullifying his power.
But, on AC, how can we be in disagreement if we both posted that we think he was a civ? Are you even reading my posts or are you just responding in a way that fits a narrative you’re trying to create? It’s obvious that people would like to see me lynched, is this your way of pushing that?
Have you ever been mafia before, because a lot of people don’t really handle it well the first time
Had some more notes, writeup threw me off
Point to your “hold off on lynching him (dummies can be added additionally) and check him at night” post.
It took a ton from me to even get half an idea like that out of you.
4:35 AM 1/16/2014
He’s giving you shit about the other way he gave me shit for not saying something. Pistol Shrimp Willy?
4:43 AM 1/16/2014
I was referring to the Witness Protection Program, had we done that he wouldn’t have died. I was all for lynching him when he role claimed with like 4 votes. Role Claiming in that instance was too akward to believe it was real.
Well it’s bedtime here so I’ll make this brief.
I found it interesting that you think they’ve chosen the LG block over an additional member. It’s not really jesus toast if you’ve written explicitly that you strongly believe that mafia will be using their LG block this next night phase. It’s not inferring that you said something you didn’t, or using any causal logic. It’s just pointing out your choice of words and adamance in the belief that mafia chose one LG stock over a 6th recruit.
To what end though? Roleclaim gives us a potential candidate for medic, or a mafioso in disguise using it to kite another lynch. Do we believe that our medic will have a well-informed plan to root out the mafia?
Personally, I find it improbable that mafia will go to the effort of keeping the medic alive but enforced. Since MP is openly confirming that mafia have hit a ship with their enforcement, as well as whether that ship is a cruiser or a scout ship, mafia can easily use this as a means of role hunting in tandem with their night kill.
I disagree that Chief was the more likely target for <Pimp Willy> to target. It’s entirely possible, but I still think AC’s approach was the more solid of the two. I apologize, I misread your speculations and thought you were calling AC mafia getting silenced. Perhaps someone before you said that? It’s been a long day so you’ll forgive me my lapse in concentration.
I’m actually not interested in seeing you on the chopping block this day phase at all. I really want to keep a strong presence in the game, considering how quiet 80% of the players are.
Just know that you have set off some alarms for me, and your conviction that mafia have a LG stock has made me curious.
I have been mafia once in the DR game, as well as being an unaligned serial killer in the RE game.
Yeah, it was Hax who said that AC might have been mafia targetted by their own, not me. How you confused me and hax I’ll never know lol.
Why else would they silence AC though? If he is Civ, and they silenced him, and he got the name… then what? AC is gonna give it to use eventually. Seems like a wasted silence. If they took the last gasp block, they didn’t take the extra member, and so they really want <Pimp Willy> on their side, so they’d HAVE to follow that plan. Silencing AC, to me, means they most likely took the last gasp block. Or I could be way off base, who knows.
60 % of the time, I’m right every time.
I think that Pimp Willy might actually be <Pimp Willy>
That was me with a quick look at Silencing,
seeing that using it on their own teammates is likely possible.
Chief can have 3 names
Alpha can have 1.
And when Alpha returns after silencing, if Chief has 3 names, and then Alpha tries to push a name that late, lol. Also lol, Syn’s metaphor made me think of a Fuzz vs AC Battleship game over skype.
Lando is Banned from Final Round
Akuma is banned from ST
Oni is banned.
& Akuma is Oni
& LandoniAkuma is banned. It was probably his third strike. :sad:
Except if they can push the angle that he was Mafia, that won’t go far if we see through the <Kaz> claim. Who else would’ve been the better player to silence to mixup the town? You have been silenced and know how frustrating that wait is. We needed a ton more out of him, and he generally got a benefit to him as a Mafia. And if civ, a benefit to the Mafia team by making sure he can’t talk.
How far will people go to think AC is a Mafia, probably not all the way to the lynch today.
Post Count:
Spoiler
**Pimp Willy** Posts: 68
**WTF-AKUMA-HAX** Posts: 49
**RadicalFuzz** Posts: 48
**AlphaCommando** Posts: 45
**The Chief** Posts: 41
**orochizoolander** Posts: 33
**Saitsu** Posts: 30
**Sumazndude** Posts: 26
**Vynce** Posts: 26
**bloodymess** Posts: 23
**GodotsRevenge** Posts: 23
**DarkGeneral** Posts: 20
**Synonym** Posts: 19
**pietastic** Posts: 14
**Augustus** Posts: 11
**kaz** Posts: 11
**ForgeDigger** Posts: 11
**Exodus.** Posts: 11
**ItzJustRellik** Posts: 10
**Blindknagg** Posts: 9
**Bious** Posts: 9
**Combo_Knight** Posts: 8
**Manx** Posts: 7
**Aidebit** Posts: 4
**Oerba** Posts: 3
**The Co-Jones** Posts: 3
**BullDancer** Posts: 2
**lol_Mafia** Posts: 2
**Shinkuu Tatsumaki** Posts: 2
**Hecatom** Posts: 2
**RECESSIONTIME** Posts: 2
**DaRabidDuckie** Posts: 1
**Cyntalan** Posts: 1
Analysis complete
Like they didn’t know, going into that Night phase what <Pimp Willy> would do. & the angle on <PW> would reveal himself to Chief didn’t seem likely, expecting <PW> to choose someone who looked pretty Civ - according to the votes, beyond “I don’t trust Chief” statements where nobody was ready to vote him out but did follow him in the Fuzz vote, along with others heading the lynch.
Like they <PW> didn’t know that Chief would get to die soon and confirm them, plus <PW> goes and guarantees he doesn’t win? He was that quick to pull the trigger on this second target, for a 50/50 instead of the one he was being led to, like why would Chief be getting picked by <PW> - and why do you think Chief was Notorious BIG over here Ready to Die, and not see day 2?
Damn, confusing. Why are we even talking about this? It came up better than Vigi shooting him, maybe, anyway? Take that, Oerba! voting me for no reason ‘just becaus XD’
