dude it’s still the first day. I have suspicions on people too, but to start throwing up random numbers with nothing to back them, especially for just a list of random people, lacks any sense. Besides, throwing up several names like u did just reeks of a mafia tactic. I’m willing to bet at least one of those people in that list is mafia, and is probably in your monster group. Pick 3 random people who’s gameplay worries your group, and add somebody you’re willing to sacrifice (in this case I am guessing Icege), then hope the town does the work for you.
The Jailer can be turned without it being obvious. We wouldnt necessarily know to lynch him. Right? unless im missing something. So, it still strikes me as a huge risk.
Let me say it this way: Do you know who the Jailer is?
What I meant by “cheating” was for him to out himself as the Jailer, be it subtly or openly, so he could get recruited. Let’s say this plan happens and he knows most every role, and he claims at the beginning of a night phase. Is one Mafia faction going to yield to the other when a prize as juicy as knowing multiple roles is at stake? I’d wager that both sides would try to Bite him, even if it ended in a tie. In that scenario we lynch him the next day, his allegiance is solidified as civilian, and he leaves us the identities if he feels it will help us. If he feels otherwise then he takes them to the Loser’s Lounge.
I was gonna originally make you Ike, but you took away your Ryu Avi, and Missing person seems like a better pick for Ike, considering his backstory with the whole er tranny thing.
You know how Ike and Soren are so close and whatnot.
also everyone forgot about underline for the lynch votes. Look into the psychology of copying, following the leader, forgetting what you already know, how to play and everything!
Why are we afraid to say that many Mafia pulled strings then also voted for Co Jones? & questioning the reasons why people bandwagoned, or going back to who first introduced that choice of vote?
You already know people bandwagoned so they can’t answer that they didn’t. This is a night phase to get information without the fear of a lot of crazy crap happening because we talked too much.
Unfortunatly Jones was the perfect scapegoat. We can’t assume that anyone knew that fucker had a role because he never posted. Sure some Mafia might have bandwagoned, but thanks to all the split votes this phase it’d be too difficult picking em out.
Its still a good idea to get those votes back for the next lynch by informing the bandwagoners to think critically about their choice, why, who told them to vote this way and if they should realize they have been swayed.
(However, yeah I did follow Bious, but wanted to no lynch the whole way. Where Chief saw me ever saying I wanted to lynch pietastic, I do not know.)
While also asking what they think about pietastic. Is he one of them too, an unlucky civ who wanted to vote co-jones out, or worse.
