Is it list time, for everybody to post their 3 biggest suspects?
Individually we can be wrong, but collectively we have to be right
Mafia gloating&Taunting threats. Or shitty Civs who want everyone dead rather than to win.
Sorry if this sounds like what people have told me: “Shut up and don’t even help.” But less of that would be nice for the mood of the game to give me a reason to want to help.
No vote count = one less thing to make your Night action choices on, in order to find a Mafia.
Godots might be gone for the night but he’s PST, I think.
A bonus to Fuzz’s mistake, hiding all the Mafia (Bandwagon) Votes
I agree that we need actual vote counts for it to be fair
however I will be surprised if anybody didn’t just vote RF given our plan
raises hand
Well I meant people actually reading the thread
I voted Mobius.
**How to play a Mafia game:
**
@SomeJerk’sName if possible - and ask them who they want to vote for. You force them to at least make one post they can’t edit in the game thread. Its info to recall later after the voting results. It is a good tool against the wallflowers and people who will not post who they voted to lynch, in the game type of sending in the vote, because they don’t even have to. You can get a Mafia voter to post this way and get them out of hiding.
As of now? WAH is still my #1. After that? zoo and mobius. Sorry PW, but I just don’t buy that he’s the UC. Maybe it’s just epic mistrust thanks to your lie, but he just isn’t giving me that vibe. I think the above may adjust tonight depending on who goes down (besides the obvious suspect going down).
Hey now, that was uncalled fo—
Actually, no, that was totally called for. :sad:
ForgeDigger, WAH, and The Chief.
But really, most of the unconfirmed look shady. It’s frustrating because I usually do a decent job of narrowing it down. Or at least I like to think I do.
Alright well I’m off to bed. See you guys on the flip side.
@Azure, we need to have a pow-wow.
I know you’re deadset in your ways, but if there was any way I could sway you, I brought you something.
It’s apple.
Or else we’re gonna make with a lot of work to get ourselves out of this hole.
Feel me?
Your thoughts on who can be UC, including DG’s idea that Chief “could be that role again, but its unlikely”
Not now, in your upcoming last gasp if its coming soon. Its of course not particularly safe to come to conclusions on who else is / or can be UC during the night phase. Like Hecatom not giving up both roles he had was a good idea, only 1 at a time, saving that for any final last gasp he gets - yes even if supermodel got screwed.
Anything on
Augustus
Cyntalan
Forge
Mobius
As wallflowers, how helpful have their ideas been, if they voiced anything before voting (“I’m unsure, I hope you guys are right”), and how they have reacted to the outcomes of votes or night phases - changing their ideas, going back to hiding until needed or pinged by the group if we remember that they didn’t answer something.
Anything you already have and not some last second, do all the work for me and us on the actual Monday night thing instead of sleeping here. Just kinda the thing you can do “before its too late,” and might do later in loser lounge.
Things that line up with being Mafia instead of an important Civilian role that should not come forward and be killed before they have enough good info and could be hiding for that reason too.
Shit, also don’t forget to detail all protections including tonight in case we don’t know if Mafia shot you or your target - if its unluckily not in the writeup too.
Listing out our suspects now would make it just make it easy for the mafia to choose accordingly who to kill in an attempt to incriminate/exonerate. But right now, that doesn’t seem to matter to them as they are content with their role-hunting reads.
So to update my list accordingly,
it would be Pietastic, Synonym and ForgeDigger.
We still don’t know what allegiance TCJ was so another suspect may do us well.
Augustus, how much weight have placed in considering that some of the mafia might have thrown AlphaCommando under the bus as early as possible?
This was an insightful post from Hecatom,
The concept I’m referring to is, more or less, similar, except, what if the mafia plan was to throw a well known, AlphaCommando, with a few of their members voting him and deeming guilty him as early as possible, this way if AlphaCommando ends up getting lynched, they will be viewed in a better light for the reminder of the game?
1 or 2 mafia members will suffice.
At that time, there were 21 possible voters, so, I or 2 votes may not have mattered, the mafia surmised.
And seeing that Bious had exposed Alpha as the forgery target, I’m inclined to believe they have more than enough incentive to do so.
Chief, and WAH for sure. I don’t feel really strongly about anyone else, but I guess I’d choose Hecatom. And that’s based solely on very flimsy evidence.
which we know now and I didn’t read it over enough, but I thought he gave up the other player
having known one role/supermodel too which he wasn’t ready to say yet?
Or vice versa, gambler+supermodel?
All I know is he gave me up. Still mad about that. :mad:
I think I figured out who HAX is.
Not giving it away yet, but if I’m right, he’s right, there’s no information that can be gleaned from his death.
I’m going to send in a guess to Godots, post-game if I tell you guys I was right, he can confirm it then.
I’m going to send in a guess to Godots, post-game if I tell you guys I was right, he can confirm it then.