I am three pages in and I hopped back here to check on the progress (Hot damn this thread moves FAST!) and I noticed that Fudd is still on the radar.
I just want to point out that Pimp Willy was the first one to finger Fudd and is still doing it rather subtly. He also tried to sway us against voting to lynch inactives, which could mean either:
He’s genuinely trying to protect civs, since inactives tend to be civ more often than not
or -
He’s Mafia scum trying to protect an fellow mafia in the inactive pool.
Again, I’ve only read the first three pages so far, but I find it odd that he’s still on a lynch Fudd bandwagon that he started. Follow that bandwagon. Make connections.
Sorry for missing the first vote. I did not think we’d be started THAT soon!
I am not trying to put anything on you, I was just saying that it was weird to mark someone off who had not checked in. I even said it was probably not something to be looked into too deeply and just because I think a certain way does not mean you have to. I just wanted to get others thoughts because in past games mafia have given left themselves up because of little slip ups.
Anyways, I gotta say, after reading this thread, some niggas try WAAAAAY too hard to analyse this. This is my first ever Mafia game, so you gotta count my rookie status. I don’t know the ins and outs to be making essay posts on why this nigga is suspicious or that nigga is.
THOUGH IF YOU ASK ME, I think that nigga makin fuckin programs to analyse posts is pretty OTT. Trying super hard to make us turn against each other could be mafia behavior.
Honestly I think the game is at a point where its too soon to really analyse, so throwing out fingers based on behavior is not a sure bet yet. Be that as it may we do HAVE to vote. I have PMed beta my vote
Although I’ll put my vote with whoever is getting the most, I still have my eye on Neesa…
She’s been contributing very little, and seems to post things just to stay active… weak analysis of the game and commentary that pushes nothing forward…
Not to mention the miscount… that is highly suspicious… I can simply not account for that being a new player mistake…
Nickrocks and Neesa play like they are barely playing(if that makes any sense), but Nickrocks could just be trolling while Neesa’s playstyle seems very much deliberate…
Deliberate? Not at all. I do other things like… y’know, packing. I have a weak analysis cause I really don’t understand it as well as I assumed that I did. So to be honest, this will probably be the last game I play in. Just wanted to give it a try to say I tried.
Miscount was an honest mistake, hence getting things cleared up with my list.
But what about you, BD? You’re rehashing information if you do post and sitting back in the cut by not contributing enough.
All of your posts sound like ‘I have no clue what is going on’ as a method of deflection for EVERYTHING…
You’re suspicious, but the game has not progressed far enough to make a determination… even as an overzealous citizen in my first game, I never played that card in order to prevent myself from being lynched… and I never defended myself by saying that the person making the accusation should be lynched…
Sadly, I really don’t know what’s going on. Probably because I can’t really focus on it. I don’t want to forfeit myself like a bitch, why I’m trying, but not to the extent as others in the game.
It’s too early for me to really make any sort of determination of anything or anyone. I’m not gonna be DRD and make charts to throw niggas off… Not gonna make bullshit accusations for it to be thrown in my face later. Playing cautious cause I am new and I’d rather not fuck up royally.
That and packin’ for my new place takes precedence over this. /Shrug
I’m not too keen on watching both of you get put on the block just yet for process of elimination. Firstly because I’ve got nothing solid on either of you, and secondly because the trade between the two of you is interesting and drawing others (myself included) into the fray.
The mention of Ben piques my interest. He’s been far more inactive than he usually is on the boards in general. Almost forgot he was in this game, and that in itself is a bit suspicious to me. This is not his first rodeo, so I don’t think he’s falling into the same category as Neesa and possibly NickGuy of just not having a complete grasp on the mechanics yet.
I think Neesa is putting forth an effort, but the speed this thread is moving and the volume of players makes it hard to ease into this game as a first time player. I don’t see that same effort from Nick, and he’s raising some questions. On this page alone both Nick and Manx have either tried to defend Fudd or deflect attention towards PimpWilly.
I won’t go out on a limb and say PimpWilly is probably a civ, but Fudd is topping the list of “suspicious-looking-most-likely-a-mafia” right now. He’s barely attempting to defend himself, so others defending him looks even more questionable. Bious taking a hit from the Mafia could also mean he was barking up the right tree on that.
I only go for a few hours and this threads increase like 2 more pages
Now that more players are starting to show is becoming more difficult to “read” the possible intentions behind what they post.
@Vynce
I actually understand pretty well of why i am on your suspects list, after all i made the huge rookie mistake to behave like i usually do on other threads where we usually shit on each others on a trollish way.
Now, i am the only one worried about this?
1st of all i thought that it was against the rules to pm between each other if we were not part of the avengers or part of the mafia.
2nd Has pataka posted here yet, i don’t remember right now so i have to go back and check, but still, it is someting really fishy, not only because pataka but sikwidit as well, it will be helpful if you post a screenshot of said pm.
And finally, i guess that we really don’t have a consensus to follow now right?, i see a lot of fingers being point, and to many opinions, but nothing in concrete yet which really worries me, i don’t have to remind you that this is the night where Taskmaster can use their ability to kill someone of us with one of his bullets, add the mafia and the possibility that we lynch another civ it will be 3 civs more to be down, and without a semi automatic final gasp or role reveal we don’t know if we are already losing important people to win this game.
And if the GR kills another one today we will be 4 man down if he kills another civilian
Or that mafia is trying to set us up. I am in no way trying to defend him because he is still up there, it is just that my suspicions stem from the same reasons for my suspicions for OZ except some slight differences. The point being is OZ came up as a civ so I want to be somewhat cautious and really talk about it before we all decide to lynch him.
Also @kaz why do you keep giving hints rather than say what you are trying to say. If you keep trying to say something without saying it mafia might try to take you out before we get the information that could help us win. Do you have a good reason for not just saying what you mean?
So you’re silent all game, and the first post you make in forevers is to randomly accuse a noob of…being a noob?
Nick, you’re too laid back to be Mafia lol
I love how many people are basing their votes on day 00 random shots in the dark. “Ohh!! XXXXX said he didn’t trust YYYYYY! Damn, that means YYYYYY has gotta be Mafia!”
it will be 3 civs more to be down, and without a semi automatic final gasp or role reveal we don’t know if we are already losing important people to win this game.