He was also obvious about his role though, thus my original post of not to giving out hints.
I enjoyed this game, can’t wait for the next round. Hopefully sometime after SRK fixes all these server issues. The first few days I couldn’t get pages to load at all when I’d try to go back and read through posts. Made me look even more useless than I already was as a first time player.
I think I made decent use of being roleless in the end though. 
I maintain that AOL is the reason you died and BJ lived.
AOL?
What the fuck is AOL
The majority duration of the mafia communication was done in an AIM chat room. Couldn’t choose between BJ, you, and… Redbeard I think? So…
One “//roll-dice 1-sides 3” later yielded a 2.
The rest is history.
You guys lost the game based on that roll…
Ok, let me ask this? Why was it between me and BJ? What was the thought process?
To be fair, this game was already a lost cause by the end of day 1. Spent the entire game trying to do damage control and finding ways to make the rest of us not look like total shit. Though I believe, at the time, we were all just looking to pick off vets, for this very reason. Night 1 was either you, Beta, or BJ.
Actually after night 1 I told SWBeta it was a wrap for the cult because you guys were talking about offing BJ. We started brainstorming future games haha. Losing Dramatix was bad, but had BJ died night 2 this game goes way different
I may do tiers… need to see cult chat probably to rank them properly. Tiers typically make everyone butthurt haha
I will post the mafia chat logs tonight…
Yeah, the die roll came on night 3, when we were all still at a loss. I don’t think it woulda come to that had we done it night 2.
Well despite the fuck up, y’all still pushed it pretty far. GGs.
I dont think I became obvious about my hints until around day 2 or more likely day 3. For awhile I was just throwing out names that Psycho should hit, and I’d mix it up every so often. I’d suggest one ‘known’ mafia, and then the rest civs I knew were civ, then I’d wait to see who kept pointing fingers. Kaz kept pointing at BD a lot, so Kaz got the chop. By last few days I was liking every psycho post, and every one of my posts was discussing what psycho should do. Redbeard drawing heat from me was interesting to say the least.
You sure got me. I was like 'I think Redbeard’s either the leader or psycho so if he dies he’s the leader and if he lives he’s the psycho.'
Really I had suspicions about everyone but just went with the best option to me most of the time.
from early on, I was absolutely certain that civs = you, redbeard, oerba, BJ, BD, LGP, MP. I just had to sort through the rest, with a hatchet.
You didn’t think I was civ? Fuck you nigga, we no longer cool.
oh i knew you were civ from the first votes actually, u just died so fast it didn’t matter lol. When you had people trying to throw lynch votes at you on day one, evn when everybody else was voting dramatix, I knew you wouldn’t last long lol. Mafia was terrified of you off the bat.
I went into this pretty untrusting.
I searched you early on cause of you and Kaz buddying up. If I had searched Kaz, I think the game would’ve been different.
Next night I searched Cyntalin cause of… Something he said or did… I forgot, but again, if it wasn’t for his ability…
Third night I went for Doof basically cause of him voting for Shinkuu. I remember almost sending Exodus then going “wait, let me make sure,” then switched it to Doof who, like he said, screwed up and protected someone else (likely Kaz.)
From then on I was basically worthless but checked DRD anyway, then the final night I checked Cyntalin again (and got murdered by him.)
Next time I need to look for the hints, I missed a crapload of things. Beta also really threw me off my stay quiet plan and made me more vocal than I’d have liked to be.
I think doof forged kaz each night. So it would have been tough to catch him as sheriff
Don’t know why lol. I was only hot on Kaz due to his “suspect” list which was all Civs and his lack of reasoning why he picked us. Which was bad on his part, IMO. I was off on the rest, thus my C performance. The Shinku push had be just knowing BJ was dirty lol.