Just got caught up on the thread.
I don’t see how anyone could have missed that Sovi3t was the vigilante. If I was mafia, I would have sniped his obvious ass the second time his prediction came true. Even if you missed that. He kept saying “I AM CONFIRMED. I AM SAFE.” As mafia, you didn’t need anything else.
Also, never change your night kill vote that early in a game. You could have taken out Warlock in night 2 and won the game.
The three-way civilian collusion at the end was pretty fun to see. At least, it was fun to see if you knew that it was all a ploy to flush out the initiate and the mafia leader. I want to see more smart and fun plays like that from civilians in future mafia games.
Most of the rest of you were pretty horrible at the game. Bad enough that I had to temporarily forget the many mafia game strats and patterns I’ve learned over the years and just dumb myself down to the most basic level of play to half-understand what was going on. What the fuck were you doing, Bulldancer? DaRabidDuckie? Ben Perkins? Doofenshmirtz? Dramatix?
Granted, some of you are brand new or still kind of new, but if I rolled up on you, seduced your girl right in front of you, and pulled a taxi for us to go to my place, would you stand there and take it? Learn to stand up and fucking defend yourselves, dummies (BP, Doof). My forehead hurts from all the facepalming I was doing reading some of that dumb shit. Don’t fucking offer yourself as a free lynch from day 1, numbnuts (Bull). Charts help, but they’re not the end-all, be-all. Don’t use it as your sole basis of deduction (DRD). I thought you were the Sheriff because you used the phrase “my investigations” in one post. Because you were brand new, I thought you pulled a Dramatix and said shit you weren’t supposed to. This was before you started posting color-coded Excel graphs and shit. Once you started doing that, I was like “yeah, he’s no fucking Sheriff.” There’s only one person I know that plays using math/statistics that is terrifyingly good. You need many more mafia games under your belt to build up your accuracy.
I knew Kaz was probably mafia when I died night 1. Mafia could have easily won if they were more aggressive. Cyntalan basically just gave the game away at the end.
May post more later, we’ll see.
Also, letting you live another night helped people think Redneck was a rookie who was just following orders. Also it would look terrible if I call a lynch against you, then when it fails you get psycho’d. Anywho, I called you out, as I always do, because you’re so animated when I do. Doesn’t matter if I think you are mafia or not (both times I actually recall actively pursuing you, you’ve been mafia), you carry it on well, and other people get involved. You’re a great way to assess who is and isn’t mafia, at a later time. The wrong people backed you up, and the right people jumped on board. And it didn’t help your cause that once I called you out, you ‘knew who I was’. I figured for sure I was dying after you said that, btw. I basically played along and agreed with you a lot, in the hopes it would keep me alive.
Will be nice to play with PW though.