The SF4 scene is still there. But they don’t have good leadership. If you aren’t VSav, ST or 3S, then you don’t have good community people who know what legit grassroot stuff is all about.
They’re slowly getting their shit together though. The side tourney at Combo Breaker 2019 had 54, CEO had 35, Evo is likely to have a lot.
Yeah you could random people out through sheer lab work, but SF4 was heavy on the neutral. Super heavy on it. Look back at old matches and just time how much time is spent fighting over space. You could do more with playing solid in SF4 because it was hard to force yourself in through force of will in a character’s moveset. You weren’t going to dash in easy, you couldn’t spend one bar on a hella fast EX move that left you + on block etc.
Hell I’ve watched more replays of SF4 finals than I have of SF5 finals during SF5s run.
Its obvious people like it. I’ve come to the conclusion that in some level I really like SF5 despite being garage. People are definitely willing to be a lot more lowkey about SF4’s shitty things than SF5 shitty. SF5 shitty is usually “oh no, I have to take this 50/50”, SF4 shitty was “oh no, how do I open up somebody who can crouch tech + probably has some other garbage OS on top of it and maybe backdash”.
Remember, I guess it doesn’t matter than an OS cover 4 different options as long as it doesn’t cover 5.
There’s a couple of things going on:
-
SF5 sucks.
-
Because SF5 sucks, people are exploring all the other GREAT games going all over the scene. In a lot of ways the SF4 crowd sort of matured and now understand why the FGC is awesome and a headache: great games all over the place.
Even if SF5 was amazing, you’d still have T7, KoF 14 (which is legit great), UNIST, Xrd 2, BBTag etc. There’s just hella good games to play right now. Kids in the FGC have it amazing.
As a scene overall, we did a terrible job of explaining how the FGC actually functioned for decades:
-
Most of the time you’re playing casuals locally.
-
Then y’all take trips together to regional tourneys most often.
-
You plan for 1 major or maybe 2 if you could afford it.
Instead you get people who go to majors before locals. But we also did a really bad job of passing really emphasizing the ground level organization. Big tournaments took more and more focus because of streams. So it sort of distorted the whole of how the scene functioned to newcomers.
Smash is one of the 5-6 pillar IPs of every modern Nintendo console since 64. So you have the most obnoxious fanbase guaranteed to buy one of the 10 worthwhile games that are going to come out for their consoles each gen. But Smash games relatively have little competition for their space. You have Rivals of Aether et al, but smash players like nintendo characters too much to try anything else. So smashers stay in smash and their whole scene is basically 2 games.
Guess how crazy the FGC would be if all of our numbers were only on 2 games?