Ruin my day: why can't Soul Calibur be the best 3D fighting game ever?

I have my opinions of things like anyone else, but ultimately I’m always on the road for more knowledge. To that end, sometimes one must face the bitter truth.

So, having said all that, I must know: Soul Calibur is my favorite 3D fighting game but no one ever seems to agree. So then…why is it not a popular opinion?

Be as brutally honest and analytical as you have to be in order to make your point. I just want to finally see this game for what it actually is and not what I think it is.

@Preppy
Troll thread

Because people have different opinions. shrug Take it up with your friends one by one if you really need to. =]

/thread