Melee or Street Fighter: Which requires more technical skill? Any Thoughts?

I’ve played Melee competitively and play SFIV competitively. Don’t be confused with SSB64 or Brawl. Melee requires much much more technical skill. There is basically an infinite level of execution in Melee. A level of execution that far surpasses even Guilty Gear.

The reason why SFIV is such a good game is that execution isn’t terribly hard and that players can move onto mindgames and poking/spacing very quickly. In Melee, the game is mostly decided by your technical skill and playstyle. Of course there are heavy amounts mindgames and spacing involved in Melee, but it is more so that one’s execution is simply better than the opponent’s, which leads to overpowering playstyles beating out others very consistantly rather than mixed player results.

LOL I know dude, I mean look at all this skill.
[media=youtube]mfreEy2tWLg&feature=related[/media]

Please tell me I’m being trolled hard LoL. This game reminds me of Power Stone. A really fun party game. Power Stone didn’t become as big as Melee, why? Because it didn’t have Link and Pikachu in it. Other than that, there is no other reason why Power Stone isn’t confused as a tourney level fighter, and Melee magically is.

Let’s face it, the N64 generation got fucked when it came to fighting games and they flocked to a game where “Level of Execution” = “Omg, this is hard because I’m doing moves on an N64 controller, somebody please shoot me.”

This is what these Smash players are good for. When they troll SRK the least they can do is provide some laughs.

LMAO. First time I’ve ever heard someone called a giraffe cunt. That’s creativity right there.

By the way, regarding Lucretz’s comic, the part about smashfuckers breaking a stick is true. Couple of them little fuckers broke Jayjay’s stick last year and ran the fuck away.

MvC3 thread… check
CvS3 thread… double check
BB vs KOF XII thread … yup it’s there
Smash Bros thread in FGD… check
Smash vs SF thread… wow, it’s there

Well it’s official, the record has been broken, how much farther will it go :rofl:

Please tell me about the part where Yoshi fucked their shit was true too.

Please?

Sadly not.

I just realized I used the word “fuck” three times in 2 sentences. Sorry, that incident just really angered me last year.

You guys don’t understand what Umeshoryu is saying.
He is saying there is an infinite level of execution in Smash, as in, people being executed in incomprehensible numbers.
They have brought mucha disuguracu to their famiries, and to people who play competitive beat em up games in general. Therefore, in the guerrilla state that is SRK, they either have the choice of having their worthless lives ended by a cranial Falcon Punch, immolated in PK Fire, or death by digestion in Kirby’s digestive tract. It takes him 2 weeks to fully digest his meals, slowly dissolving and sloughing off their flesh and muscle. Not what you might have hoped from death by a fucking Saturday morning Fox Box cartoon. But what do they know? When you’re too busy beating your dick to cartoon princesses like it’s a minority in an LAPD station, you don’t have time for research.

it’s cool, you’re a canadian so you’re allowed to be angry.

[media=youtube]6cVBQLsyPyw[/media]

[media=youtube]8wODO-1bv-k[/media]

This level of play is a level none of you will achieve. There is such a high level of technical skill and mindgames that none of you here will ever understand(which in this case, none of you do). And from looking at the way you guys post, you will never get close to even being decent at SFIV with your closed mindsets, unable to accept different types of fighting games just because they’re different.

I really feel sorry for you noobs who think SFIV is the shit. I really do =( Seriously, SFIV is a baby’s game compared to competitive Melee. You noobs complaining about Sagat or not being able to land your little SRK FADC Ultra. Really really sad.

Oh and feel free to challenge me on Xbox anytime, I’ll ruin your day, definitely.

i play babby game!
babby game fight you game and beat up! there is no do with this!

Yay more Smash faggotry, whoa was that a shine spike?
I saw some sweetspot knees, oh my gosh my erection will not cease
SO PRO, HOW YOU DO THIS

Those words don’t register to Smash players, what are you doing?

Let me give you a tip.

Don’t bother.

Regardless of how well thought out your argument are and how much evidence you post the only responses you will get are going to be memes and bandwagon posts.

Spend your time doing something more productive.

Many people didn’t believe Jesus was the son of God when he was still alive. Maybe Melee just needs to die and ascend to heaven before people understand. Or maybe Jesus wasn’t the son of God, who knows?

SRK has to be like, the only forum I know of, where an obvious troll thread will appear and will succeed every single time because nobody can resist posting in it just to flame the OP or derail the thread.

It’s like, troll heaven. Want some attention? Want that thread to stick around good long time? SRK will give it to you.

okay when smash came out i was like wow nintendo is marketing a game solely to me because i hate low attacks!

Melee requires more technical skill.

I thought the quota was met for this month. Guess not. We’ll count this as the Marvel 3 thread for database purposes.

I dunno, we still need a couple of “I’m making a fighting game even though I don’t know how!” threads.