I’m assuming that’s we understand to be “soft banned.” As in, they’re still allowed in tournaments, but the players there generally don’t pick them out of respect for the community or something like that. I can’t recall who exactly said it, but I’m pretty sure it was Mattsun and Kurahashi, and the others sort of seemed to silently agree.
Ryu, Ken, and Sagat are all strong in their old versions, but that’s the main reason why you don’t see them being used by a majority of players. This even extends to O.Hawk to a lesser extreme. O.Hawk is just flat out a better character, yet most of the Hawk players use N.Hawk.
Older version of characters are sometimes better because of better properties on their hit and hurt boxes. They weren’t as close together as they are nowadays, so usually a lot of them have beastly range and priority. Generally, it makes up for their lack of throw softening or burst damage from a super combo, so it’s really just Ryu, Ken. Sagat, and Hawk’s old versions that you have to worry about.
Eventhubs tier list is garbage. I mean, not only do a vast majority of ST players NOT go to that website regularly, but most of that developed tier list was polled from the general public with limited or no knowledge of ST whatsoever.
We actually had this argument recently on the main FB page where we talk about ST. Yes, both old shotos have 50/50 unblockable tatsus on wakeup. I swear it’s higher than this, since Damdai hit me at LEAST 60-70% of the time during our grand finals match at Don’s Arcade. But honestly, not a huge deal, since it’s really only effective against a small handful of matches (Gief, Boxer, Sim, Dictator), and even then there are ways to get out of it. It’s just a part of the game. No point complaining about it, since it’s not going to get patched anytime soon, and I highly doubt there will be bans on it.
Yeah, just a cultural thing. Since they don’t have cash prizes in tournaments, there’s less of an incentive to whore out to a top tier and win at all costs. It seems FAR more important to represent your character well and play nice with your local community. Things tend to be far more aggressive and combative here in the States 