Okay time to resurrect this thread.
My take on the tier list is strictly my opinion and it’s simply here to restart the tier discussion thread now that the game has been out and a few tourneys have been run. I also want to mention that this list is a combination tier list and match up chart in that everybody under S tier is ranked based on how well they do against S tier characters, and not necessarily the rest of the cast. So if you see someone much lower, or higher than they should be, that’s part of the reason why. That said, I’m pretty confident of this tier list
SS: Kyo
S: Iori, Terry, Robert, Joe
A: Andy, Athena, Leona, Shen Woo
B: Raiden, Ralf, Ash, Ryo, Chin
C: Clark, Kensou, Benimaru, Elizabeth
D: Kim, Duo Lon, Mature, Goro
Kyo gets his own rank because he has the tools to beat everybody in the game, including the other S ranks, minus Joe, more on Joe later.
Iori has even better mix ups then Kyo, but his damage isn’t as good and he has to get in close, which is a dangerous if your opponent has meter.
Terry’s damage is easily the best in the game. His only drawback is that none of his attacks are safe, but that really means squat if you can’t output comparable damage to bring Terry down anyway.
Robert’s debatable but I think he deserves S rank because of all his options, if you include his cross up kick and both supers. He’s perfect for last position if your second character landed just a bit of damage on your opponent’s last guy, which is easy time over win for Robert.
Now Joe is tricky, because I don’t feel that he’s as scary as the other 3 S rank members, but my reasoning for Joe to be up here is that he’s probably the only character that can really fight Kyo evenly due to equal priority/safety, which is huge.
Okay so the A rank characters listed all require meter to defeat the S rank characters, but each of them have some nice tricks, like small hit boxes that make them hard to combo into dust, or can dish out serious damage/mix ups to keep the S ranks on their toes the entire fight.
B tier characters are extremely strong, but can’t cover their weaknesses as well as the A tier characters so the S ranks pretty much stomp on them when they are out of meter.
C tier characters are average at best, they have the tools to win against S rank characters, but they have to take too many risks for not enough damage to be considered A or B ranks. Now Clark, a lot of people say he should be bottom tier, but I feel that Clark is strong; he just has a much higher learning curve then the rest of the cast to master his Vulcan Punch/Air Throw combos. However you can just forget about trying to use Clark online thanks to input delay, and the already bad throw mechanics.
D tier characters are also average but meter itself is not enough to save them, from the S ranks; they need CC too to defeat them. These characters have some serious character flaws that really put them at a disadvantage against the S ranks, and I would say that Kyo owns them, but not for free. However they are also not well known, so using them effectively can give you the element of surprise making them good back up characters.