Help me fix my arcade controls! new sticks? octagonal gate?

Hi!

I’m an old school SF2 player. Played it non-stop in the arcades for years in high school and college.

About 10 years ago, many years after I stopped playing in the arcades, I hired someone over the internet to build me some arcade sticks for use with MAME. I tried my best to research what type of sticks I liked when playing in the arcades but it was difficult to describe and guess. I knew that I preferred sticks where I could FEEL the corners, and not sticks that felt smooth all the way around (I hated when I played on a machine with those). At the time the guy that built my sticks recommended, I believe, Happ sticks and I think that’s what I got.

Well, I liked the controls in general but pretty much hated the sticks. They feel, to me, smooth all the way around so I have a hard time finding the corners. I’d like to do something about that because I have a reignited interest in setting up a good MAME system here.

After some research I THINK I want something with an octagonal gate. I wonder if I might have played on a square gate, but since I am from the US it seems octagonal is more likely. I’d know it if I felt and played it, but that’s hard for me to do.

From what I can tell I cannot install a gate on my Happ sticks. Does that seem correct? If not, I’d like to replace my sticks with something I would prefer.

Anyone have any recommendations on sticks/gates? Recommended vendors to buy from?

Here are some pics of my current controls.

Any help greatly appreciated! Thanks!

[Easier to Replace With a Japanese stick with a Bat top](Happ IndustriasLorenzo style 3D printed square gate stick

That user seemed to want the same feel you wanted. You may want to try a Sanwa JLF witch comes with a square gate. You can buy the octagonal gate insert to try out as well. Then buy the bat top adapter.
You may have to research if the JLF can mount where your HAPP mounting holes are as well.

Thanks for the reply! I tried to search about the hole patter, but found a thread that indicates because of the length of Sanwa sticks they may not stick out enough since my controls are made of wood… ugh!

http://www.neo-geo.com/forums/showthread.php?172617-Has-anyone-fitted-a-sanwa-stick-to-happ-drilled-holes-cough

After thinking about it a bit more I do think a square gate is probably what I liked back in the arcade days. But it would probably be nice to try an octagonal gate as well.