I’ll be frank. The “community” lacks dedication. But before that, lacks true/genuine interest in KOF as a whole.
Before KOFXIII, the KOF “community” in the US as represented by online forums were just a bunch of scrubs that were probably some poor ethnic minority that picked up some KOF collections at the bargain bin in some Gamestop and just keep wishlisting for characters rather than be able to use their means to actually learn and play the game. GGPO, Supercade, nfba with kaillera were good enough means to learn the fundamentals of KOF and to enjoy playing KOF with others. The only good players in the US are just expatriates that come from other nations and have already developed their skills elsewhere. When I ask players on GGPO that are represented by the US flag that I find to be decent/good/great players, they’re often from China/Taiwan/Morocco/Pakistan/Anywhere but homegrown US players.
Post KOFXIII, we have a bunch of people that “latched” onto the game but quickly fell of as fast they got on. Same things are happening to other new games as well that aren’t the main Capcom games, and even these communities seem to have stagnant growth in skill level.
We especially saw the decline in participation as soon as Persona came out and even Persona’s scene rapidly dwindled.
If a person truly enjoys the game or its series with sincerity, that person will find a way to play it and enjoy it. One way or another.
A great thing about KOF is that basic system doesn’t change that much from each generational series (96-98 Normal, 99-2000 Strikers, 03-XI Tag, 02/XIII Variation of Normal) unlike going from SFII to Alpha Series, to III Series. If a person really wanted to learn how to play KOF, they’d find a means to play a form at KOF to improve his or her own overall KOF skill. Even learning a different KOF game from one’s “main KOF” game helps broaden one’s perspective of one’s characters to help define one’s general understanding of the toolset.
If people can’t play XIII online, there are still other very accessible KOF games with stable enough online. Even if XIII is a person’s “main KOF” that shouldn’t give them an excuse to not enjoy the rest of the series and expand their overall knowledge of KOF. And it’s not as if one has to stop playing XIII if one picks up another KOF, just go back into XIII’s training mode to refreshen up on slightly different timings, particular set ups, and or KOF XIII specific characters such as Hwa Jai or Mr. Karate.
With that said, it doesn’t help that KOF XIII, as much as it’s called an “honest” game, doesn’t reward that much for what it emphasized in older games. It’s still a pretty fraudy game. HD combo damage output is worse than Ultras but at least doesn’t function as silly as X Factor. Anti-air normals have been purposely nerfed by SNKP. More specials/supers that are faster and more invul than any other KOF game. Etc., etc. The game rewards more reckless, idiotic play as long as someone grinding more combos and meter managing than actual spacing and ground game. There’s a reason why the game is still called “kusoge.”
So let’s say one dedicates his or her time solely to KOF XIII, it’s still as if they’re not really learning KOF. Just a more shallow shell of what it used to be. At least Climax stepped it up from the stupidity that KOF XIII Arcade was and what XII was. I still feel that the devs know what they’re doing unlike Capcom devs; but, they’re intentionally trying to appeal to the lowest common denominator like everyone else is doing.
In the end it’s all moot, everyone else’s dedication, commitment, or genuine passion for “playing and growing with the game” has been apparent before XIII or even XII was released and it’s still apparent now.
Once my new stick comes in since my refurbished PSX pad that I bought at EVO last minute finally gave out, I’ll still be playing on GGPO and Supercade in KOF98. Just I have been for the past 3 years since I touched KOF for the first time.
I still tool around 98um’s, XI’s, 02um’s, and XIII’s training modes just so I can be warmed and ready at Major’s and EVO’s to play any of those games at BYOC just by the off chance someone else wants to play KOF with me.
I like KOF. I play KOF. I learn KOF.