I have not played Evil Ryu of course but Albo and Carltwo mentioned a lot of things that I agree with and mentioned about Evil Ryu from watching all the different videos of him. Here is my own breakdown of how I see Evil Ryu
-Normals: Average. Lights can be chained, MP is pretty good, but still doesn’t have the same kind of reach as the Shoto cr. MK. Evil Ryu also lacks Ryu’s assortment of links. Including combo’ing into sweep like most Shoto’s can.
-Damage: Great. Yes Evil Ryu can hit like a truck. Problem is that he doesn’t have a good way to get that combo started. We’ll see that combo from time to time(mainly off punishes), but it won’t be too often during high level play.
-Zoning: Good. He might have the best fireball game in the game. His start up and recovery looks to be on par or better then Ryu. His anti airs are as good as regular Ryu. Problem is that projectile characters aren’t so good in AE.
-Focus Attack: Great. It has long reach and looks cool, nuff said.
-Ultras: Great. He may have the best combo in the game. Both do pretty damage on FADC, even partial Ultra 2 hurts quite a bit. And after focus crumple, both are pretty good since a point blank Metsu Hado does more damage.
-Mix ups: Average. A nice improvement from Ryu, but far from Akuma’s vortex. Dive kick, resets after tatsu, and having the EX axe kick all contribute to a decent mix up game.
Overall: Good. If this were Super, he could be top 5 but since we’re talking about AE I think he’ll be upper mid as Cartwo also said. He’s good, but not broken. Even if he were 1000 health/stun, he might barely be top 5, but still definitely not apart of the argument for best character in the game(IMO).
Of course I’m just playing theory fighter right now. But even top players have said the same thing. When Yun and Yang became available, everybody just knew they were going to be really good after some time with them. The same can’t be said for Evil Ryu and Oni. And I think that’s too bad. They have a cool look, but don’t strike fear like the twins do. Like I said, I wish these two would have been overpowered and extremely low health instead of what we have now.