Best budget stick amongst these?

Tech Talk
1

Hello everyone, first post here,
Im kind of a newcomer in SF (started with 4) and Im kind of fed up with my Xbox One controller, even after 100+ hours with it I keep dropping lots of inputs every single match, so Im looking to invest in a budget stick to see if it fits me (dont go hori rap on me, Im not looking to drop that kind of money yet)
So I looked around and found these contenders which fit my budget, looking for your feedback on these or other suggestions, I’ll include the price on each one bc I think price/quality might be relevant:
Lioncast Arcade Fighting Stick 30€
https://www.amazon.es/Lioncast-Arcade-Fighting-Controlador-Joystick/dp/B004L3VU8S/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1524371098&sr=8-3&keywords=arcade+stick
Unnamed Mayflash 37€
https://www.amazon.es/USB-Fighting-Stick-Mayflash-PS2/dp/B0015PHMFU/ref=sr_1_9?ie=UTF8&qid=1524372744&sr=8-9&keywords=arcade+stick
MadCatZ Arcade Stick Alpha 37€
https://www.amazon.es/Mad-Catz-Street-Fighter-Arcade/dp/B019CQKCOQ/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1524372744&sr=8-5&keywords=arcade+stick
Hori Fighting Stick Mini 40€
(No image bc no Amazon listing, but I can get it)

Mayflash F300 54€
https://www.amazon.es/Mayflash-Arcade-Joystick-Fightstick-F300/dp/B019MFPLC0/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1524372744&sr=8-4&keywords=arcade+stick
And finally Qanba Carbon 60€~ → I couldnt find a place to order this in Spain, but I heard its around this price

Looking forward to your opinions, thanks in advance!

EDIT: Oh, and Im playing on PC
EDIT2: Added Hori Mini

2

From the list you’ve provided, I suggest the Mayflash F300

3

Posted also on r/StreetFighter and got the same feedback so far, nonetheless Im open to any suggestion as long as we stay in the price bracket
Thanks for your feedback!

4

I have to agree with jopamo and r/StreetFighter. Out of that list the Mayflash F300 is the best option. 2nd best option is the Carbon.

As for other suggestions, if you don’t mind buying a used stick (and since you play on PC), you can always try eBay (or other equivalent sites). You can find some good deal for last gen sticks. Don’t really know the prices for Spain, but it’s just a suggestion.

5

The F300 was my first stick and I really liked it, but it has little space for the left hand and that may be uncomfortable if you have big hands. Other than that it’s a nice starting stick, just make sure you give it some time, it takes a while to get used to playing on a stick.

6

Thanks everyone for your feedback, I narrowed it down to Mayflash F300 and Qanba Q1/Carbon, will be getting one of these 2.

Best of luck!

7

just be aware that qanba carbon doesn’t work on anything but pc and ps3. it might work on ps4 with certain games, but not all, and it won’t work whatsoever on xbox one with the stock pcb.

apart from multi console compatibility, whats better about the f300?